Beddingfield Richard, Pedro Renato N, Hinck Bryan, Kreidberg Carly, Feia Kendall, Monga Manoj
Department of Urologic Surgery, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA.
J Urol. 2009 Jan;181(1):170-6. doi: 10.1016/j.juro.2008.09.026. Epub 2008 Nov 14.
We assessed the impact of alfuzosin on ureteral stent discomfort.
A total of 66 patients scheduled for unilateral retrograde ureteroscopy with stent placement provided consent for the study. Patients were randomized between placebo and the study medication, and investigators and patients were blinded to the randomization scheme. To evaluate pain and urinary symptoms patients were asked to complete the Ureteral Stent Symptom Questionnaire (Stone Management Unit, Southmead Hospital, Westbury-on-Trym, United Kingdom) before ureteroscopy and 3 days after the procedure to minimize the confounding impact of procedural discomfort due to surgery. Patients were also asked to maintain a use log of pain medication each day that the ureteral stent was in place. Procedure outcome and complications were recorded, as were patient study medication use and vital health information before the procedure and at the time of stent removal. Statistical analysis was performed using the Student t, chi-square and Wilcoxon rank sum tests, as appropriate, with p <0.05 considered significant.
Of 66 patients who provided consent 55 successfully completed the study. In 3 of the 11 failed cases surgery was not done due to spontaneous stone passage, surgery was performed in 3 but no ureteral stent was placed, 4 were excluded from study after obtaining consent due to exclusion criteria and 1 was voluntarily removed from study after obtaining consent but before surgery. Regarding stent type, procedure complications and baseline questionnaire results there were no significant differences between the placebo and alfuzosin arms. When comparing post-procedure questionnaire results, patients in the alfuzosin arm reported less overall pain in the kidney/back/loin area and less pain in the kidney area while passing urine (p = 0.017 and 0.007, respectively). Men in the alfuzosin arm also reported a lesser incidence of excessive urination (p = 0.040). When comparing changes from baseline questionnaire results, the alfuzosin arm experienced a decrease in kidney pain during sleep (p = 0.017), less frequent use of painkillers to control kidney pain (p = 0.020) and a decrease in how much kidney associated pain interfered with life (p = 0.045). There was no significant difference in the amount of narcotics used per day, as reported in patient medication logs.
Alfuzosin improves the patient discomfort associated with ureteral stents by decreasing urinary symptoms and kidney pain but it does not affect the amount of narcotics that patients use while the stent is in place.
我们评估了阿夫唑嗪对输尿管支架不适的影响。
共有66例计划接受单侧逆行输尿管镜检查并放置支架的患者同意参与本研究。患者被随机分为安慰剂组和研究药物组,研究者和患者均对随机分组方案不知情。为评估疼痛和泌尿系统症状,患者被要求在输尿管镜检查前及检查后3天完成输尿管支架症状问卷(英国南米德医院结石治疗科),以尽量减少手术引起的操作不适的混杂影响。患者还被要求在输尿管支架留置期间每天记录止痛药的使用情况。记录手术结果和并发症,以及患者在手术前和支架取出时的研究药物使用情况和重要健康信息。根据情况使用Student t检验、卡方检验和Wilcoxon秩和检验进行统计分析,p<0.05被认为具有统计学意义。
66例同意参与研究的患者中,55例成功完成研究。在11例未成功的病例中,3例因结石自行排出未进行手术,3例进行了手术但未放置输尿管支架,4例因不符合纳入标准在获得同意后被排除在研究之外,1例在获得同意后但手术前自愿退出研究。在支架类型、手术并发症和基线问卷结果方面,安慰剂组和阿夫唑嗪组之间没有显著差异。比较术后问卷结果时,阿夫唑嗪组患者报告肾脏/背部/腰部区域的总体疼痛较轻,排尿时肾脏区域的疼痛较轻(分别为p = 0.017和0.007)。阿夫唑嗪组的男性患者尿频发生率也较低(p = 0.040)。比较基线问卷结果的变化时,阿夫唑嗪组睡眠期间肾脏疼痛减轻(p = 0.017),控制肾脏疼痛使用止痛药的频率降低(p = 0.020),肾脏相关疼痛对生活的干扰减少(p = 0.045)。患者药物使用记录显示,每天使用的麻醉药量没有显著差异。
阿夫唑嗪通过减轻泌尿系统症状和肾脏疼痛改善了与输尿管支架相关的患者不适,但不影响患者在支架留置期间使用的麻醉药量。