Yip Linwah, Ogilvie Jennifer B, Challinor Susan M, Salata Rose A, Thull Darcy L, Yim John H, Carty Sally E
Division of Endocrine Surgery, School of Medicine, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA, USA.
Surgery. 2008 Dec;144(6):1002-6; discussion 1006-7. doi: 10.1016/j.surg.2008.07.030.
In the evaluation of patients with primary hyperparathyroidism (PHP), specific query for a personal or family history of MEN1 (Hx) is recommended widely, but responses are rarely positiv. We instituted a 6-question panel (6Q) to routinely screen for MEN1 preoperatively.
The clinical database entries of 939 patients explored for apparent sporadic PHP from June 1992 to November 2007 were examined for presenting diagnosis, demographics, anatomic findings, MEN1 analysis, and final diagnosis. To directly compare the results of 6Q and Hx, we also reviewed the charts of 654/939 PHP patients screened systematically from January 2000 to November 2007.
MEN1 was undiagnosed until the preoperative evaluation in 1.6% of patients referred with apparent sporadic PHP. To date, MEN1 has been diagnosed in 42 of 939 (4.5%) PHP patients. Compared with those who have sporadic PHP, MEN1 patients were often male (38.1% vs 20.2%; P = .005) and young (mean, 38 +/- 17 years vs 60 +/- 13 years; P < .001). When hyperplasia was present at initial parathyroid exploration, the likelihood of MEN1 was 26% (32/123). For the 15 patients diagnosed by a surgeon to have MEN1, Hx was positive in 3 patients (20%) and 6Q in 13 (87%) (P = .0002). In a multivariate analysis of 635 patients with negative Hx, the likelihood of MEN1 increased with (1) younger age at initial parathyroid exploration and (2) number of positive 6Q responses.
MEN1 occurs relatively often and can be missed. Systematic use of a simple 6-question panel helps to identify MEN1 prior to parathyroid exploration. Young male patients with parathyroid hyperplasia and positive 6Q results should be evaluated for MEN1.
在原发性甲状旁腺功能亢进症(PHP)患者的评估中,广泛推荐专门询问患者本人或家族性MEN1病史(Hx),但回答很少呈阳性。我们制定了一个6问题小组(6Q),用于术前常规筛查MEN1。
检查了1992年6月至2007年11月期间因明显散发性PHP而接受检查的939例患者的临床数据库记录,以了解其现患诊断、人口统计学、解剖学发现、MEN1分析和最终诊断。为了直接比较6Q和Hx的结果,我们还查阅了2000年1月至2007年11月期间系统筛查的654/939例PHP患者的病历。
在以明显散发性PHP转诊的患者中,直到术前评估才有1.6%的患者被诊断出患有MEN1。迄今为止,939例PHP患者中有42例(4.5%)被诊断出患有MEN1。与散发性PHP患者相比,MEN1患者多为男性(38.1%对20.2%;P = 0.005)且年龄较轻(平均38±17岁对60±13岁;P < 0.001)。当初次甲状旁腺探查发现增生时,MEN1的可能性为26%(32/123)。对于外科医生诊断为患有MEN1的15例患者,Hx呈阳性的有3例(20%),6Q呈阳性的有13例(87%)(P = 0.0002)。在对635例Hx为阴性的患者进行多变量分析时,MEN1的可能性随着(1)初次甲状旁腺探查时年龄较轻和(2)6Q阳性回答的数量增加而增加。
MEN1相对常见且可能被漏诊。系统使用一个简单的6问题小组有助于在甲状旁腺探查前识别MEN1。甲状旁腺增生且6Q结果为阳性的年轻男性患者应接受MEN1评估。