Vaiva G, Jehel L, Cottencin O, Ducrocq F, Duchet C, Omnes C, Genest P, Rouillon F, Roelandt J-L
Secteur des urgences psychiatriques, pôle des urgences, CHRU de Lille, Lille, France.
Encephale. 2008 Dec;34(6):577-83. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2007.11.006. Epub 2008 Apr 2.
Trauma-related disorders are disabling affections of which epidemiological data change according to the country, population and measuring instruments. The prevalence of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) appears to have increased over the past 15 years, but one cannot tell whether it has indeed increased or whether the standardized procedure has improved. Moreover, very few epidemiologic studies among the general population have been conducted in Europe, notably in France.
The "Santé mentale en population générale" (SMPG) survey, that took place in France between 1999 and 2003 among more than 36 000 individuals, gives an estimation of the prevalence of psychotraumatic disorders in the general population. Multi-varied analyses were performed on PTSD-related variables and comorbid disorders. The instantaneous prevalence (past month) of PTSD was of 0.7% among the whole SMPG sample, with almost the same proportion of men (45%) and women (55%). There was a high rate of comorbidity among PTSD individuals, notably with mood disorders, anxiety disorders and addictive behaviour. There was an obvious relationship with suicidal behaviour, with 15-fold more suicide attempts during the past month among the PTSD population.
This survey analysed the consequences of a psychic traumatism over and above complete PTSD according to DSM-IV criteria, observing for instance the consequences for people exposed both to a trauma and suffering from at least one psychopathological symptom since the trauma. Those who suffered from a psychotraumatic syndrome, according to our enlarged definition, represented 5.3% of the population, half suffered from daily discomfort and a third of them used medication. Then, we compared those psychotraumatic syndromes to complete PTSD from a sociodemographic, functional and type of care point of view. There was little difference in prevalence of PTSD between men and women in the SMPG survey (45% vs 55%), which is clearly distinct from the other epidemiologic surveys named above. Regarding age, as in the ESEMeD survey, anxiety disorders appeared to be more frequent among younger people. The originality of the SMPG survey is obviously in the fact that it studied the functional impact of the psychic disorder, the type of care and the satisfaction level after care. Only 50% of the PTSD population feels sick which is, however, twice as high as for the psychotraumatized population. This doesn't fit either with the fact that 100% of the PTSD population say they feel uncomfortable with other people. The type of care is in the same vein: 50% of psychotherapies and 75% of medication, but also 25% of mild medicines and 25% of traditional medicines. Moreover, among the drugs, antidepressants (that are still the first choice treatment in all international recommendations) represent only 30%, whereas anxiolytics, hypnotics and phytotherapy represent the remaining 70%.
Regarding the type of care, the differences between the psychotraumatized population and the PTSD population are obvious. They are obvious in that which concerns the type of care, since the medication is similar. From a very global point of view, patients suffering from a subsyndromal PTSD rarely choose medical care (religion, mild or traditional medicine), while full PTSD patients definitely choose classical medical care (drugs, psychotherapy, and 30% of hospitalization). The prevalence of those who ask for care is very close to that observed in the ESEMeD survey, which was four individuals out of 10 suffering from PTSD.
The SMPG data show that its necessary to maintain the distinction between subsyndromal PTSD and full PTSD since the populations differ, but both need care.
创伤相关障碍是致残性疾病,其流行病学数据因国家、人群和测量工具而异。过去15年中,创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)的患病率似乎有所上升,但无法确定这是实际增加还是标准化程序有所改进。此外,在欧洲,尤其是法国,针对普通人群的流行病学研究非常少。
1999年至2003年在法国对36000多人进行的“普通人群心理健康”(SMPG)调查,对普通人群中精神创伤性障碍的患病率进行了估计。对与PTSD相关的变量和共病障碍进行了多变量分析。在整个SMPG样本中,PTSD的即时患病率(过去一个月)为0.7%,男性(45%)和女性(55%)的比例几乎相同。PTSD患者的共病率很高,尤其是与情绪障碍、焦虑障碍和成瘾行为。与自杀行为有明显关系,PTSD人群中过去一个月的自杀未遂次数是其他人群的15倍。
本次调查分析了根据《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第四版(DSM-IV)标准,除完全PTSD外的精神创伤的后果,例如观察自创伤以来既遭受创伤又患有至少一种精神病理症状的人的后果。根据我们扩大的定义,患有精神创伤综合征的人占人口的5.3%,其中一半人每天感到不适,三分之一的人使用药物治疗。然后,我们从社会人口统计学、功能和护理类型的角度将这些精神创伤综合征与完全PTSD进行了比较。在SMPG调查中,男性和女性的PTSD患病率几乎没有差异(45%对55%),这与上述其他流行病学调查明显不同。关于年龄,与欧洲精神疾病流行病学调查(ESEMeD)一样,焦虑障碍在年轻人中似乎更常见。SMPG调查的独特之处显然在于它研究了精神障碍的功能影响、护理类型和护理后的满意度。只有50%的PTSD患者感到不适,但这是精神创伤人群的两倍。这也不符合100%的PTSD患者表示他们与他人相处感到不舒服这一事实。护理类型也是如此:50%接受心理治疗,75%使用药物治疗,还有25%使用温和药物和25%使用传统药物。此外,在药物中,抗抑郁药(在所有国际指南中仍然是首选治疗药物)仅占30%,而抗焦虑药、催眠药和植物疗法占其余的70%。
关于护理类型,精神创伤人群和PTSD人群之间的差异很明显。在护理类型方面差异明显,因为药物治疗相似。从非常宏观的角度来看,患有亚综合征PTSD的患者很少选择医疗护理(宗教、温和或传统药物),而完全PTSD患者肯定会选择经典医疗护理(药物、心理治疗和30%的住院治疗)。寻求护理的人群患病率与ESEMeD调查中观察到的非常接近,即每10名PTSD患者中有4人。
SMPG数据表明,有必要区分亚综合征PTSD和完全PTSD,因为这两类人群不同,但两者都需要护理。