Haddy T B, Czajka-Narins D M, Sky-Peck H H, White S L
Department of Pediatrics and Child Health, Howard University College of Medicine, Washington, DC.
Public Health Rep. 1991 Sep-Oct;106(5):557-63.
Hair mineral analysis can be used as a reliable screening test for heavy metals, but it is not an established method for defining nutritional and disease states. Wide variation in test results is a major problem in utilizing the technique for clinical purposes. Better reference values are needed, especially for children, as well as information about how hair mineral values correlate with body fluid values. A total of 48 black children were studied. Of these, 20 were normal children, ages 1 to 17; 12 were normal infants, ages 5 weeks to 12 months; 3 were children with iron overload; 7 had iron deficiency anemia; and 6 had thalassemia trait. There were in all 17 boys and 31 girls. The distribution of 15 minerals in hair, serum, and urine samples was determined by energy dispersive X-ray fluorescence. Mineral concentrations from the normal children were compared with concentrations obtained from the children with iron overload, iron deficiency anemia, and thalassemia trait. Statistical analysis revealed no significant differences among any of the groups. Mineral concentrations from the normal infants and children may be useful as reference values. The analysis of hair iron as a valid screening test for body iron status in children is not supported by our data.
头发矿物质分析可作为一种可靠的重金属筛查测试,但它并非确定营养和疾病状态的既定方法。测试结果差异巨大是将该技术用于临床目的时的一个主要问题。需要更好的参考值,尤其是针对儿童的参考值,以及关于头发矿物质值与体液值如何关联的信息。共对48名黑人儿童进行了研究。其中,20名是1至17岁的正常儿童;12名是5周龄至12个月龄的正常婴儿;3名是铁过载儿童;7名患有缺铁性贫血;6名有地中海贫血特质。共有17名男孩和31名女孩。通过能量色散X射线荧光法测定头发、血清和尿液样本中15种矿物质的分布。将正常儿童的矿物质浓度与铁过载、缺铁性贫血和地中海贫血特质儿童的浓度进行比较。统计分析表明各组之间无显著差异。正常婴儿和儿童的矿物质浓度可用作参考值。我们的数据不支持将头发铁分析作为儿童体内铁状态的有效筛查测试。