Hanlon Joseph T, Aspinall Sherrie L, Semla Todd P, Weisbord Steven D, Fried Linda F, Good C Bernie, Fine Michael J, Stone Roslyn A, Pugh Mary Jo V, Rossi Michelle I, Handler Steven M
Department of Medicine, University of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15213, USA.
J Am Geriatr Soc. 2009 Feb;57(2):335-40. doi: 10.1111/j.1532-5415.2008.02098.x. Epub 2008 Dec 10.
To establish consensus oral dosing guidelines for primarily renally cleared medications prescribed for older adults.
Literature search followed by a two-round modified Delphi survey.
A nationally representative survey of experts in geriatric clinical pharmacy.
Eleven geriatric clinical pharmacists.
After a comprehensive literature search and review by an investigative group of six physicians (2 general internal medicine, 2 nephrology, 2 geriatrics), 43 dosing recommendations for 30 medications at various levels of renal function were created. The expert panel rated its agreement with each of these 43 dosing recommendations using a 5-point Likert scale (1=strongly disagree to 5=strongly agree). Recommendation-specific means and 95% confidence intervals were estimated. Consensus was defined as a lower 95% confidence limit of greater than 4.0 for the recommendation-specific mean score.
The response rate was 81.8% (9/11) for the first round. All respondents who completed the first round also completed the second round. The expert panel reached consensus on 26 recommendations involving 18 (60%) medications. For 10 medications (chlorpropamide, colchicine, cotrimoxazole, glyburide, meperidine, nitrofurantoin, probenecid, propoxyphene, spironolactone, and triamterene), the consensus recommendation was not to use the medication in older adults below a specified level of renal function (e.g., creatinine clearance <30 mL/min). For the remaining eight medications (acyclovir, amantadine, ciprofloxacin, gabapentin, memantine, ranitidine, rimantadine, and valacyclovir), specific recommendations for dose reduction or interval extension were made.
An expert panel of geriatric clinical pharmacists was able to reach consensus agreement on a number of oral medications that are primarily renally cleared.
为老年人开具的主要经肾脏清除的药物制定共识性口服给药指南。
文献检索后进行两轮改良德尔菲调查。
对老年临床药学专家进行的具有全国代表性的调查。
11名老年临床药师。
在由6名医生(2名普通内科医生、2名肾病科医生、2名老年病科医生)组成的调查小组进行全面的文献检索和综述后,针对30种药物在不同肾功能水平下制定了43条给药建议。专家小组使用5点李克特量表(1 = 强烈不同意至5 = 强烈同意)对其与这43条给药建议中的每一条的一致性进行评分。估计了特定建议的均值和95%置信区间。共识定义为特定建议的平均得分的95%置信下限大于4.0。
第一轮的回复率为81.8%(9/11)。所有完成第一轮的受访者也完成了第二轮。专家小组就涉及18种(60%)药物的26条建议达成了共识。对于10种药物(氯磺丙脲、秋水仙碱、复方新诺明、格列本脲、哌替啶、呋喃妥因、丙磺舒、丙氧芬、螺内酯和氨苯蝶啶),共识建议是在肾功能低于特定水平(例如,肌酐清除率<30 mL/分钟)的老年人中不使用该药物。对于其余8种药物(阿昔洛韦、金刚烷胺、环丙沙星、加巴喷丁、美金刚、雷尼替丁、金刚乙胺和伐昔洛韦),给出了减少剂量或延长给药间隔的具体建议。
老年临床药师专家小组能够就许多主要经肾脏清除的口服药物达成共识。