Seyrek-Intas Deniz, Michele Ursula, Tacke Sabine, Kramer Martin, Gerwing Martin
Department of Veterinary Clinical Sciences, Clinic for Small Animals-Surgery, Justus-Liebig University, 35392 Giessen, Germany.
J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2009 Feb 15;234(4):480-5. doi: 10.2460/javma.234.4.480.
To determine the accuracy of ultrasonography in detecting fragmentation of the medial coronoid process (FMCP) in dogs.
Cross-sectional study.
102 dogs (112 elbow joints) suspected to have FMCP.
Elbows were examined ultrasonographically prior to surgery for evidence of fragmentation, fissuring, or deformation of the medial coronoid process; thickening of the joint capsule; joint effusion; and secondary new bone formation. Results were compared with intraoperative findings.
At surgery, 51 (46%) joints had free fragments, 55 (49%) had nondisplaced fragments, and 6 (5%) did not have any fragments or fissures. Fragments were not seen ultrasonographically in 23 of the 51 (45%) joints in which a free fragment was found during surgery or in 50 of the 55 (91%) joints in which a nondisplaced fragment was found during surgery. Accuracy of using ultrasonographic evidence of any medial coronoid process abnormality (ie, a medial coronoid process fragment, deformation of the medial coronoid process, or both) for diagnosis of medial coronoid process fragmentation was 77%. The kappa coefficient for the level of agreement between ultrasonographic (ie, any medial coronoid process abnormality) and surgical findings was -0.014, indicating that there was no agreement.
Results suggested that ultrasonography was of limited diagnostic value in detecting FMCP in dogs.
确定超声检查在检测犬内侧冠状突骨折(FMCP)方面的准确性。
横断面研究。
102只疑似患有FMCP的犬(112个肘关节)。
在手术前对肘关节进行超声检查,以寻找内侧冠状突骨折、裂隙或变形的证据;关节囊增厚;关节积液;以及继发性新骨形成。将结果与术中发现进行比较。
手术时,51个(46%)关节有游离碎片,55个(49%)有关节内无移位碎片,6个(5%)没有任何碎片或裂隙。在手术中发现有游离碎片的51个关节中的23个(45%),或在手术中发现有关节内无移位碎片的55个关节中的50个(91%),超声检查未发现碎片。使用内侧冠状突任何异常的超声证据(即内侧冠状突碎片、内侧冠状突变形或两者皆有)诊断内侧冠状突骨折的准确性为77%。超声检查(即内侧冠状突任何异常)与手术结果之间的一致性水平kappa系数为-0.014,表明两者之间无一致性。
结果表明,超声检查在检测犬FMCP方面的诊断价值有限。