Miles Mark, Kemmitt Greg, Bakker Frank, Aldershof Saskia
Dow AgroSciences, European Development Centre, Abingdon, OX14 4RN, UK.
Commun Agric Appl Biol Sci. 2008;73(3):409-17.
Two Large scale field studies have been conducted to the same design in commercial apple orchards in north and south France. Mancozeb (Dithane M-45) was applied at its post-annex I use rate of 1.6 kg a.i./ha on four occasions with a spray interval of 7 days. Reference treatments of a water treated control and toxic reference of dimethoate were also included. Studies were of randomized block design with 4 replicates (4 plots of 6 adjacent rows of 8 trees, on a surface of approximately 16 x 21 m) per treatment. Leaf and canopy dwelling arthropods were sampled before and at regular intervals after application until the end of the season. A diverse range of arthropod taxa was sampled, counted and identified which enabled for an evaluation of key taxa such as predatory mites and other beneficials but also of the whole foliar dwelling arthropod community. This two level analysis allows for a thorough investigation of both direct and indirect effects of the test item on beneficial, pest and non-target arthropods and for a state of the art evaluation at the ecological community Level using ordination techniques. The findings from the two locations were highly consistent in that mancozeb applied four times at 1.6 g a.i./ha with a 7 day spray interval caused significant but short lived reductions in predatory Phytoseiid mites of >50% with rapid recovery approximately one month after application. These transient effects did not impact secondary pests such as rust mites (Eriophyoidea) and broad mites (Tarsonemidae). A wide range of arthropod taxa were investigated (229 taxa in the north and 215 taxa in the south) and consistent adverse treatment related effects were not noted for any taxa other than Phytoseiidae. At a lower rate of mancozeb representing potential off-field deposits at 3 m due to drift effects were virtually absent on predatory mites in and to all other taxa present.
在法国北部和南部的商业苹果园中,按照相同设计进行了两项大规模田间研究。代森锰锌(大生M-45)以其附件I规定的使用剂量1.6千克有效成分/公顷,分四次施用,喷雾间隔为7天。还设置了水处理对照和乐果毒性对照的参考处理。研究采用随机区组设计,每个处理有4个重复(4个小区,每个小区有6排相邻的8棵树,面积约为16×21米)。在施药前以及施药后定期对叶栖和冠层节肢动物进行采样,直至季节结束。对多种节肢动物类群进行了采样、计数和鉴定,这有助于评估关键类群,如捕食螨和其他有益生物,以及整个叶栖节肢动物群落。这种两级分析能够全面研究测试项目对有益、有害和非目标节肢动物的直接和间接影响,并使用排序技术在生态群落水平上进行最新评估。两个地点的研究结果高度一致,即代森锰锌以1.6克有效成分/公顷的剂量分四次施用,喷雾间隔为7天,导致捕食性植绥螨显著减少,但持续时间较短,减少幅度超过50%,施药后约一个月迅速恢复。这些短暂影响并未影响锈螨(瘿螨科)和侧多食跗线螨(跗线螨科)等次要害虫。研究调查了广泛的节肢动物类群(北部229个类群,南部215个类群),除植绥螨科外,未发现其他类群有与处理相关的一致不利影响。在较低剂量的代森锰锌下,由于漂移效应,距果园3米处的潜在场外沉积物对捕食螨及所有其他存在的类群几乎没有影响。