Loggia Marco L, Bushnell M Catherine, Tétreault Martine, Thiffault Isabelle, Bhérer Claude, Mohammed Nazma K, Kuchinad Anil A, Laferrière Audrey, Dicaire Marie-Josée, Loisel Lina, Mogil Jeffrey S, Brais Bernard
Alan Edwards Centre for Research on Pain, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada H3A 2B2.
J Neurosci. 2009 Feb 18;29(7):2162-6. doi: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.4633-08.2009.
Hereditary sensory and autonomic neuropathy type 2 (HSAN2) is a rare recessive genetic disorder characterized by severe sensory loss affecting the tactile, thermal and nociceptive modalities. Although heterozygous carriers of nonsense mutations in the HSN2 gene, called with-no-lysine(K)-1 (WNK1), do not develop the disease, historical and experimental evidence suggests that these individuals might perceive somatosensory stimuli differently from others. Using the method-of-limits, we assessed the thresholds for warmth detection, cool detection, heat pain and cold pain in 25 mutation carriers and 35 controls. In group analyses, carriers displayed significantly lower warmth (p<0.001) and cool (p<0.05) difference thresholds, and also tended to report cold pain at higher temperatures (p=0.095), than controls. Similarly, matched-pair analyses showed that carriers are significantly more sensitive to warm stimuli (p<0.01) and cold pain stimuli (p<0.05), and tend to be more sensitive to cool stimuli (p=0.11). Furthermore, the differences between the warmth detection thresholds of the carriers and those of gender- and sex-matched wild types significantly increased with age (r=0.76, p=0.02), and in carriers cool detection thresholds did not increase with age (r=0.27, p=0.24) as expected and observed in controls (r=0.34, p=0.05). This study demonstrates that the carriers of a recessive mutation for HSAN2 display greater sensitivity to innocuous thermal stimuli, as well as for cold pain, suggesting a possible environmental adaptive advantage of the heterozygous state.
遗传性感觉和自主神经病变2型(HSAN2)是一种罕见的隐性遗传疾病,其特征是严重的感觉丧失,影响触觉、热觉和痛觉。尽管在名为无赖氨酸(K)-1(WNK1)的HSN2基因中存在无义突变的杂合子携带者不会发病,但历史和实验证据表明,这些个体对躯体感觉刺激的感知可能与其他人不同。我们使用极限法评估了25名突变携带者和35名对照者的热觉探测、冷觉探测、热痛和冷痛阈值。在组间分析中,与对照组相比,携带者表现出显著更低的热觉(p<0.001)和冷觉(p<0.05)差异阈值,并且在更高温度时更倾向于报告冷痛(p=0.095)。同样,配对分析表明,携带者对热刺激(p<0.01)和冷痛刺激(p<0.05)显著更敏感,并且倾向于对冷刺激更敏感(p=0.11)。此外,携带者与性别和年龄匹配的野生型之间的热觉探测阈值差异随年龄显著增加(r=0.76,p=0.02),而在携带者中,冷觉探测阈值并未如预期且在对照组中观察到的那样随年龄增加(r=0.27,p=0.24)(r=0.34,p=0.05)。这项研究表明,HSAN2隐性突变的携带者对无害热刺激以及冷痛表现出更高的敏感性,提示杂合状态可能具有环境适应性优势。