Luscombe-Marsh Natalie D, Smeets Astrid J P G, Westerterp-Plantenga Margriet S
Department of Human Biology, Maastricht University, PO Box 616, 6200 MD, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Br J Nutr. 2009 Sep;102(6):929-37. doi: 10.1017/S0007114509297212. Epub 2009 Mar 9.
In a fed and orally stimulated state, whether the addition of monosodium glutamate (MSG) (alone or in combination with inosine monophosphate-5 (IMP-5)) to a high-protein (HP) meal leads to early satiety and a difference in energy intake at a second course was investigated. Ten men and twelve women consumed, in random order, a first-course meal consisting of: (1) water (control); (2) a HP meal with 0.6% MSG and 0.25% IMP-5; (3) a HP meal with no additives; (4) a HP meal with MSG only; (5) a sham-fed meal 2 (oral-stimulation). Appetite perceptions, plasma concentrations of glucagon-like peptide 1 (GLP-1), glucose and insulin, and energy intake at a buffet (i.e. a second course) were measured before and after each condition. Changes in appetite, and in GLP-1, glucose and insulin, were similar for the three fed HP conditions and all were greater (post hoc all P < 0.01) than the control and sham conditions. Energy intake was not different following the HP+MSG+IMP (1.86 (SEM 0.3) MJ) as compared with the HP+MSG-only (2.24 (SEM 0.28) MJ) condition (P = 0.08), or for the HP+MSG+IMP compared with the HP no-additives condition (1.60 (SEM 0.29) MJ) (P = 0.21). Following the HP+MSG-only condition, 0.64 (SEM 0.20) MJ more energy was consumed compared with the HP no-additives condition (P = 0.005). We conclude that the addition of MSG to a HP meal does not influence perceptions of satiety and it may increase energy intake at a second course. Cephalic responses after the sham condition were of similar magnitude to the control and therefore just tasting food is not enough to influence appetite and energy intake.
在进食且经口腔刺激的状态下,研究了在高蛋白(HP)餐中添加味精(MSG)(单独添加或与5'-肌苷酸二钠(IMP-5)联合添加)是否会导致早期饱腹感以及第二餐时能量摄入量的差异。10名男性和12名女性按随机顺序食用了第一餐,包括:(1)水(对照);(2)含0.6%味精和0.25% IMP-5的高蛋白餐;(3)无添加剂的高蛋白餐;(4)仅含味精的高蛋白餐;(5)假饲餐2(口腔刺激)。在每种情况前后,测量食欲感知、胰高血糖素样肽1(GLP-1)、葡萄糖和胰岛素的血浆浓度以及自助餐(即第二餐)时的能量摄入量。三种进食的高蛋白餐条件下,食欲以及GLP-1、葡萄糖和胰岛素的变化相似,且均大于(事后检验所有P<0.01)对照和假饲条件。与仅添加味精的高蛋白餐(2.24(标准误0.28)兆焦)相比,添加味精和IMP-5的高蛋白餐(1.86(标准误0.3)兆焦)后的能量摄入量无差异(P = 0.08),与无添加剂的高蛋白餐(1.60(标准误0.29)兆焦)相比,添加味精和IMP-5的高蛋白餐的能量摄入量也无差异(P = 0.21)。与无添加剂的高蛋白餐相比,仅添加味精的高蛋白餐条件下多摄入了0.64(标准误0.20)兆焦的能量(P = 0.005)。我们得出结论,在高蛋白餐中添加味精不会影响饱腹感的感知,且可能会增加第二餐时的能量摄入量。假饲条件后的头期反应与对照相似,因此仅仅品尝食物不足以影响食欲和能量摄入。