Lisý M, Pink M, Skládal M, Vano M
Ortopedické oddelení Nemocnice Trebíc.
Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2009 Feb;76(1):34-40.
PURPOSE OF THE STUDY Distal radioulnar joint (DRUJ) instability often develops after distal forearm fracture or severe dislocation of the wrist with damage to its stabilising structures. The instability is usually diagnosed as a chronic condition and only rarely at the time of injury. When the stabilising structures are not treated adequately soon after injury, instability develops and is accompanied with pain, restricted range of motion and reduced grip strength. This study presents the option of chronic instability treatment by tenodesis with use of the palmaris longus tendon. Its aim is to remind the broad medical community of this issue. MATERIAL Between July 1994 and November 2000, tenodesis was performed in 15 patients with chronic DRUJ instability. The right and left sides were affected in 10 and five patients, respectively; of them 12 were dominant extremities. All injuries were diagnosed as dorsal subluxation of the ulnar head, with side dislocation in three patients. METHODS The diagnosis was based on a thorough medical history, and clinical and radiographic examination, including projections in forced maximum radial and ulnar duction, as recommended by Geyer and Luzius as early as in 1964. Tenodesis was done by the Jäger and Wirth method using the palmaris longus tendon. The patients were scored according to the Modified Mayo Wrist System. RESULTS Of the 15 patients treated by this method, 14 were evaluated. Eight patients regarded the results as very good, with no pain at maximal physical activity, and five considered them good, experiencing pain only at maximal but not at everyday activities. One patient reported a poor outcome. The average score increased from pre-operative 40 to 60 points post-operatively. All patients had a slight restriction of rotation movements of the forearm. Residual instability was found in one patient. DISCUSSION It is a common view that this condition is caused by subluxation or dislocation of the ulnar head, while in fact it is subluxation or dislocation of the radius turning around the ulna. As reported in the literature, dorsal dislocation is three-times as frequent as volnar dislocation, and this is in agreement with our findings. There is a wide variety of the operative methods for tenodesis which differ in the distribution of tunnels in bone. Restriction of the range of motion in our patients also agreed with the literature data. No effect of a distal radius fracture on the results of surgery was recorded. CONCLUSIONS Our results show that tenodesis is a method suitable to treat chronic DRUJ instability if the indication criteria are observed, i. e., if no arthritic lesions are present in the joint.
研究目的 桡尺远侧关节(DRUJ)不稳定常发生于前臂远端骨折或腕关节严重脱位并伴有其稳定结构损伤之后。这种不稳定通常被诊断为慢性疾病,很少在受伤时被诊断出来。当稳定结构在受伤后未得到充分治疗时,就会出现不稳定,并伴有疼痛、活动范围受限和握力下降。本研究提出了使用掌长肌腱进行腱固定术治疗慢性不稳定的方法。其目的是提醒广大医学界关注这个问题。
材料 在1994年7月至2000年11月期间,对15例慢性DRUJ不稳定患者进行了腱固定术。右侧和左侧受累的患者分别为10例和5例;其中12例为优势肢体。所有损伤均被诊断为尺骨头背侧半脱位,3例伴有侧方脱位。
方法 诊断基于详尽的病史、临床和影像学检查,包括早在1964年Geyer和Luzius所推荐的最大桡偏和尺偏位投照。腱固定术采用Jäger和Wirth方法,使用掌长肌腱。根据改良的梅奥腕关节系统对患者进行评分。
结果 采用该方法治疗的15例患者中,14例接受了评估。8例患者认为结果非常好,在最大体力活动时无疼痛,5例认为结果良好,仅在最大体力活动时而非日常活动时感到疼痛。1例患者报告结果不佳。平均评分从术前的40分提高到术后的60分。所有患者前臂旋转运动均有轻微受限。1例患者存在残余不稳定。
讨论 普遍认为这种情况是由尺骨头半脱位或脱位引起的,而实际上是桡骨围绕尺骨发生半脱位或脱位。正如文献报道的那样,背侧脱位的发生率是掌侧脱位的三倍,这与我们的发现一致。腱固定术有多种手术方法,在骨隧道分布上有所不同。我们患者活动范围的受限也与文献数据相符。未记录桡骨远端骨折对手术结果的影响。
结论 我们的结果表明,如果遵循适应证标准,即关节无关节炎病变,腱固定术是治疗慢性DRUJ不稳定的一种合适方法。