Kramer Dennis E, Chang Tai-Li, Miller Nancy H, Sponseller Paul D
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Childrens Hospital Boston, 300 Longwood Ave, Boston, MA 02215, USA.
Orthopedics. 2008 May;31(5):501. doi: 10.3928/01477447-20080501-14.
Simultaneous avulsions of the tibial tubercle and patellar ligament have been reported, but are rare. We present an 11-year-old boy who was initially diagnosed with a Type IIIA tibial tubercle avulsion fracture after falling off of his bicycle. Intraoperatively, following exposure and fixation of the tibial tubercle fragment, knee range of motion under live fluoroscopy revealed a stationary patella with no tension in the patellar ligament. The incision was extended and a distal avulsion of the patellar ligament from the tibial tubercle was identified, with a small flap of tibial tubercle periosteum remaining attached. Transosseous suture fixation of the avulsed periosteal flap was achieved with 2 No. 5 ethibond sutures placed through connecting drill holes. Postoperatively, the patient was placed in a long leg cast with the knee in extension for 6 weeks. The injury to healed and the patient returned to full activities, although he required 2 courses of physical therapy and 4.5 months to regain full range of motion. Preoperative diagnosis of simultaneous tibial tubercle fracture and patellar ligament avulsion can be difficult. Palpation of the patellar ligament for gaps may not be possible due to a large knee effusion. Most patients do not tolerate quadriceps testing on examination and do not have patella alta on radiographs. In retrospect, a clue to this diagnosis in our patient was the preoperative radiographic finding of multiple calcified fragments below the patella. The calcified fragments likely represent the avulsed tibial tubercle periosteum attached to the distal patellar ligament. In addition, the large tibial tubercle fragment is separated and rotated superiorly, a finding that was also noted in two other similar case reports.
胫骨结节和髌韧带同时撕脱的病例已有报道,但较为罕见。我们报告一名11岁男孩,他从自行车上摔下后最初被诊断为III A型胫骨结节撕脱骨折。术中,在暴露并固定胫骨结节骨折块后,在术中透视下观察膝关节活动范围时发现髌骨固定不动,髌韧带无张力。于是扩大切口,发现髌韧带从胫骨结节处远端撕脱,仍有一小片胫骨结节骨膜相连。通过在连接钻孔中穿过2根5号Ethibond缝线对撕脱的骨膜瓣进行经骨缝合固定。术后,患者膝关节伸直位长腿石膏固定6周。损伤愈合后,患者恢复了全部活动,不过他需要接受2个疗程的物理治疗,花4.5个月才能恢复完全活动范围。术前诊断胫骨结节骨折和髌韧带撕脱同时存在可能很困难。由于膝关节大量积液,可能无法触及髌韧带来检查有无间隙。大多数患者在检查时无法耐受股四头肌测试,X线片上也没有高位髌骨。回顾来看,我们这位患者诊断的一个线索是术前X线片上髌骨下方有多个钙化碎片。这些钙化碎片可能代表附着于髌韧带远端的撕脱胫骨结节骨膜。此外,较大的胫骨结节骨折块分离并向上旋转,另外两篇类似病例报告中也有此发现。