Komoda Takeshi, Lehmkuhl Hans B, Stiller Brigitte, Berger Felix, Hetzer Roland
Department of Cardiothoracic and Vascular Surgery, Deutsches Herzzentrum Berlin, Berlin, Germany.
Artif Organs. 2009 Apr;33(4):346-51. doi: 10.1111/j.1525-1594.2009.00725.x.
Due to the Eurotransplant organ allocation policy, urgency listing for heart transplantation (HTx) remains in force until ventricular assist device (VAD) implantation in Germany. We studied the prognosis of HTx candidates after failed donor heart allocation in urgent status. We studied all adult and pediatric (<18 years) HTx candidates who underwent primary HTx after Eurotransplant urgency listing between January 2001 and December 2006 (Group A-uHTx [A-"u"rgent status "HTx"], n = 99; Group P-uHTx [P-"u"rgent status "HTx"], n = 24) and those to whom donor heart was not urgently allocated before VAD implantation or death in the same period (Group A-fHA [A-"f"ailed "H"eart "A"llocation], n = 21, Group P-fHA [P-"f"ailed "H"eart "A"llocation], n = 10). Mortality rate after urgency listing or primary VAD implantation was studied in each group. In adult patients, 1-year mortality rate after urgency listing in Group A-fHA was 56.8% and significantly higher than in Group A-uHTx (30.6%, P < 0.001, log-rank test). After failed urgent heart allocation, 15 out of 21 patients in Group A-fHA had VAD implantation and two patients (9.5%) underwent HTx after VAD implantation. In pediatric patients, 1-year mortality rate in Group P-fHA was 40.0% and significantly higher than in Group P-uHTx (8.5%, P < 0.05). In Group P-fHA, all 10 patients underwent VAD implantation after failed urgent heart allocation and six patients (60.0%, P < 0.01 vs. Group A-fHA, Fisher's exact test) underwent HTx after VAD implantation. After failed urgent donor heart allocation, pediatric HTx candidates seem to profit more from mechanical circulatory support than adults.
由于欧洲器官移植组织(Eurotransplant)的器官分配政策,在德国,心脏移植(HTx)的紧急名单状态一直持续到植入心室辅助装置(VAD)。我们研究了处于紧急状态的心脏移植候选者在供体心脏分配失败后的预后情况。我们研究了2001年1月至2006年12月期间在欧洲器官移植组织紧急名单状态后接受初次心脏移植的所有成人及儿科(<18岁)心脏移植候选者(A组 - 紧急状态心脏移植 [A - “u”rgent status “HTx”],n = 99;P组 - 紧急状态心脏移植 [P - “u”rgent status “HTx”],n = 24),以及在同一时期在植入VAD或死亡前未被紧急分配供体心脏的那些候选者(A组 - 心脏分配失败 [A - “f”ailed “H”eart “A”llocation],n = 21;P组 - 心脏分配失败 [P - “f”ailed “H”eart “A”llocation],n = 10)。研究了每组在紧急名单状态或初次植入VAD后的死亡率。在成年患者中,A组 - 心脏分配失败组在紧急名单状态后的1年死亡率为56.8%,显著高于A组 - 紧急状态心脏移植组(30.6%,P < 0.001,对数秩检验)。在紧急心脏分配失败后,A组 - 心脏分配失败组的21名患者中有15名植入了VAD,两名患者(9.5%)在植入VAD后接受了心脏移植。在儿科患者中,P组 - 心脏分配失败组的1年死亡率为40.0%,显著高于P组 - 紧急状态心脏移植组(8.5%,P < 0.05)。在P组 - 心脏分配失败组中,所有10名患者在紧急心脏分配失败后均植入了VAD,6名患者(60.0%,与A组 - 心脏分配失败组相比P < 0.01,Fisher精确检验)在植入VAD后接受了心脏移植。在紧急供体心脏分配失败后,儿科心脏移植候选者似乎比成年患者从机械循环支持中获益更多。