A new interpretation of the mechanism of ankle fracture.

BACKGROUND

Researchers have found it difficult to recreate a Lauge-Hansen supination-external rotation-type ankle fracture in experimental settings. We hypothesized that a pronation-external rotation mechanism could cause both distal, short oblique and high fibular fractures and that the fracture type would be affected by associated, laterally directed forces applied to the foot. Methlods: Twenty-three cadaver ankles were subjected to fracture loading that replicated the Lauge-Hansen pronation-external rotation mechanism with or without applying an external lateral force. In Phase I, an axial load was applied to fifteen specimens mounted on a materials testing machine. Each foot was rotated externally to failure. In Phase II, eight specimens were tested according to the Phase-I protocol, but external forces were applied laterally at the foot to increase the abduction moment at the ankle. Load and position versus time curves were recorded and were correlated with video image data to establish the sequence of failure of specific anatomic structures.

RESULTS

Eight specimens tested in Phase I sustained an oblique fracture of the distal end of the fibula with both medial and posterior injuries that occurred after the fibular fracture. Increasing the external lateral force and hence the abduction moment within the ankle (Phase II) resulted in three of eight specimens sustaining a high fibular fracture with a reversed fracture line (anterosuperior to posteroinferior) and/or a comminuted high fibular fracture. The distribution of traditional pronation-external rotation-type fractures differed significantly between Phase I and Phase II (p=0.032).

CONCLUSIONS

This study generated counterexamples to the Lauge-Hansen classification system by showing that a short oblique fracture of the distal end of the fibula can occur with the foot in the pronated position. Furthermore, a high fibular fracture was recreated by increasing the abduction moment at the ankle.