Cornaglia C, Robinet J, Partouche H
Département de médecine générale, faculté de médecine, université Paris Descartes, 156, rue de Vaugirard, 75015 Paris, France.
Med Mal Infect. 2009 Jun;39(6):375-81. doi: 10.1016/j.medmal.2009.02.011. Epub 2009 Apr 3.
The distribution of the Rapid Antigen Detection Test (RADT) and the National Health Insurance's information campaign should efficiently reduce the unjustified use antibiotic. However, a preliminary survey among GP trainers at the Paris Descartes University indicated that the RADT was seldom used.
This study had for aim to describe the RADT use trend among trainers since 2005 and the main obstacles to its widespread use, and to assess the Mac Isaac score use and antibiotic prescriptions.
Between February and May 2007, a survey was carried out among 66 GPs who were required to report their first ten patients over three years of age presenting with pharyngitis. RADT use and antibiotic prescriptions were compared with those of the 2005 survey.
RADT use had decreased (52.5% [48.2-56.8] versus 57.5% [52.1-68.8], p<0.05). GPs did not use the RADT because they considered it "useless in decision making". Clinical findings were sufficient in most cases. The Mac Isaac score was not widely used by GPs (28.3%) and antibiotic prescription had increased except for macrolides which had decreased (10% vs 15%). Among patients with a negative RADT, 11.9% (vs 10.5% en 2005, p<0.001) were prescribed antibiotics.
The RADT use decreased in two years among GP trainers. GPs still prescribe treatment according to clinical findings, most without using diagnostic tools.
快速抗原检测试验(RADT)的推广及国家医疗保险的宣传活动应能有效减少抗生素的不合理使用。然而,巴黎笛卡尔大学针对全科医生培训师开展的一项初步调查显示,RADT很少被使用。
本研究旨在描述自2005年以来培训师中RADT的使用趋势及其广泛应用的主要障碍,并评估麦克艾萨克评分的使用情况和抗生素处方情况。
2007年2月至5月期间,对66名全科医生进行了一项调查,要求他们上报三岁以上患咽炎的前十位患者的情况。将RADT的使用情况和抗生素处方与2005年的调查结果进行比较。
RADT的使用有所下降(52.5% [48.2 - 56.8] 对比57.5% [52.1 - 68.8],p<0.05)。全科医生不使用RADT是因为他们认为其“对决策无用”。在大多数情况下,临床症状已足够。全科医生对麦克艾萨克评分的使用并不广泛(28.3%),除大环内酯类抗生素处方减少(10%对比15%)外,抗生素处方有所增加。在RADT检测结果为阴性的患者中,11.9%(对比2005年的10.5%,p<0.001)被开具了抗生素。
在两年时间里,全科医生培训师中RADT的使用有所减少。全科医生仍根据临床症状开处方,大多数情况下不使用诊断工具。