Adams Samuel B, Simpson Andrew W, Pugh Linda I, Stasikelis Peter J
Division of Orthopaedic Surgery, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC, USA.
J Pediatr Orthop. 2009 Mar;29(2):170-4. doi: 10.1097/BPO.0b013e3181982c33.
Calcaneal lengthening is a common procedure for the treatment of symptomatic planovalgus deformity in children with cerebral palsy. Stabilization of the calcaneocuboid joint to prevent subluxation at the time of lengthening has been described. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the magnitude of calcaneocuboid joint subluxation and associated degenerative changes in patients with cerebral palsy who underwent calcaneal lengthening for planovalgus foot deformity with and without stabilization of the calcaneocuboid joint.
We conducted a retrospective review of children with cerebral palsy who underwent lateral column lengthening through the calcaneus. For the purposes of statistical analysis, the feet were divided into 2 groups: stabilized (those that received Steinmann pin stabilization at the time of lengthening) and nonstabilized (those feet that did not receive Steinmann pin stabilization). Initial, intraoperative, and most recent follow-up radiographs were reviewed for segmental foot analysis of planovalgus deformity, calcaneocuboid joint subluxation, and osteoarthritic changes. A minimum of 3-year follow-up was required.
Sixty-one feet were included in this study; 28 feet in the stabilized group and 33 in the nonstabilized group. Radiographic assessment of segmental foot analysis demonstrated significant improvement with regard to planovalgus deformity (P<0.05, 5 measurements). Calcaneocuboid joint subluxation occurred in 24 feet in the stabilized group and 29 feet in the nonstabilized group (P=0.5269). At final follow-up, the magnitude of subluxation was not significantly different between the groups (P=0.076). There was no difference in the incidence of osteoarthritic changes at the calcaneocuboid joint between the groups (P=0.2856).
Lateral column lengthening through the calcaneus, for planovalgus foot deformity, significantly improved the segmental alignment of the foot with respect to radiographic assessment. Stabilization of the calcaneocuboid joint at the time of lateral column lengthening through the calcaneus did not significantly reduce the incidence or magnitude of subluxation when compared with nonstabilized lengthening. In addition, stabilization did not have an effect on the development of radiographic osteoarthritic changes at the calcaneocuboid joint.
Level III, retrospective comparative study.
跟骨延长术是治疗脑瘫患儿症状性扁平外翻畸形的常用手术。已有文献报道在延长术时稳定跟骰关节以防止半脱位。本研究的目的是评估在跟骨延长术治疗扁平外翻足畸形时,有无跟骰关节稳定的情况下,脑瘫患者跟骰关节半脱位的程度及相关退行性改变。
我们对接受经跟骨外侧柱延长术的脑瘫患儿进行了回顾性研究。为了进行统计分析,将足部分为两组:稳定组(延长术时接受斯氏针固定的患儿)和非稳定组(未接受斯氏针固定的患儿)。对初始、术中及最近一次随访的X线片进行回顾,以分析扁平外翻畸形、跟骰关节半脱位和骨关节炎改变的足部节段情况。至少需要3年的随访。
本研究共纳入61只足;稳定组28只足,非稳定组33只足。足部节段分析的影像学评估显示扁平外翻畸形有显著改善(P<0.05,5项测量指标)。稳定组24只足发生跟骰关节半脱位,非稳定组29只足发生跟骰关节半脱位(P=0.5269)。在末次随访时,两组半脱位程度无显著差异(P=0.076)。两组跟骰关节骨关节炎改变的发生率无差异(P=0.2856)。
经跟骨外侧柱延长术治疗扁平外翻足畸形,在影像学评估方面显著改善了足部节段对线。与未稳定延长术相比,在经跟骨外侧柱延长术时稳定跟骰关节并不能显著降低半脱位的发生率或程度。此外,稳定跟骰关节对跟骰关节影像学骨关节炎改变的发展没有影响。
Ⅲ级,回顾性比较研究。