Restifo Kathleen, Bögels Susan
Maastricht University, Department of Clinical Psychological Science, Postbox 616, 6200MD Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Clin Psychol Rev. 2009 Jun;29(4):294-316. doi: 10.1016/j.cpr.2009.02.005. Epub 2009 Mar 4.
There is strong evidence that family factors play a role in the development, maintenance and course of youth depression. However, to date few clinical trials of psychotherapy for youth depression employ family therapy interventions or target the known family risk factors. This is surprising given recent meta-analytic findings showing only modest effect sizes for psychotherapy for youth depression, and that cognitive therapies do not outperform non-cognitive therapies. The aim of this review is to 1) use a developmental systems approach to review empirical evidence on family risk factors for youth depression to identify potential targets for treatment, 2) examine the extent to which these family risk factors have been targeted in clinical trials for youth depression, and 3) provide a road map for the development of empirically validated family-based interventions for youth depression. Strong evidence was found supporting a relationship between family factors at multiple system levels and depressive symptoms or disorders. Support for several different hypothesized causal mechanisms as well as bidirectional effects was found. A comparison of the identified risk factors and psychotherapy trials for youth depression indicated that few RCT's target family factors; among those that do, only a few of the family risk factors are targeted. Recommendations for translation of empirical knowledge of family risk factors and mechanisms to develop empirically valid family-based interventions to enhance existing treatments for youth depression are provided.
有充分证据表明,家庭因素在青少年抑郁症的发生、维持及病程中发挥作用。然而,迄今为止,针对青少年抑郁症的心理治疗临床试验中,很少采用家庭治疗干预措施或针对已知的家庭风险因素。鉴于最近的荟萃分析结果显示,青少年抑郁症心理治疗的效应量仅为中等,且认知疗法并不优于非认知疗法,这一现象令人惊讶。本综述的目的是:1)采用发展系统方法,回顾关于青少年抑郁症家庭风险因素的实证证据,以确定潜在的治疗靶点;2)研究在青少年抑郁症临床试验中,这些家庭风险因素被作为靶点的程度;3)为开发经实证验证的青少年抑郁症家庭干预措施提供路线图。研究发现了有力证据,支持多个系统层面的家庭因素与抑郁症状或障碍之间存在关联。还发现了对几种不同的假设因果机制以及双向效应的支持。对已确定的青少年抑郁症风险因素与心理治疗试验进行比较表明,很少有随机对照试验将家庭因素作为靶点;在那些确实将家庭因素作为靶点的试验中,也只有少数家庭风险因素被纳入。本文提供了相关建议,旨在将家庭风险因素及机制的实证知识转化为经实证验证的家庭干预措施,以加强现有的青少年抑郁症治疗方法。