Institute of Neuroscience and Physiology, Division of Speech and Language Pathology, Sahlgrenska Academy at Göteborg University, Sweden.
Res Dev Disabil. 2009 Nov-Dec;30(6):1145-54. doi: 10.1016/j.ridd.2009.03.002. Epub 2009 Apr 16.
We wanted to test the hypothesis that neuropsychiatric disorder (NPD) with language impairment (LI) is a more severe variant of NPD than NPD without LI, and that this variant can be easily picked up by a non-word repetition (NWR) task. We therefore tested 56 (mean 7.6, range 6.1-9.5 years) children divided into three subgroups: one with LI only (n=8), one with NPD only (n=16) and one with a combination of LI and NPD (n=32). We used a Swedish NWR test, a real word repetition test, the Verbal Comprehension and Freedom from Distractibility factor of the WISC-III. All three subgroups had difficulties with NWR and real word repetition compared to the norm, but the within-subgroup variations were considerable. The subgroup with NPD only performed best on both NWR and real word repetitions, but remarkably poorly given that they had never been noted for having language problems. NPD with LI consistently had the lowest scores. Of the three subgroups, only NPD with LI scored lower than the normal range on Verbal Comprehension and Freedom from Distractibility. Significant correlations were found between NWR on the one hand, and Freedom from Distractibility and Verbal Comprehension, on the other, indicating that poor results on a NWR test is probably not a "clean" measure of speech and language impairment, but also taps into other neuropsychological constructs, including executive dysfunction. In conclusion, the study confirmed the hypothesis that NPD with LI constitutes a more severe variant of NPD, and that this variant can easily be picked up by a quick and easy NWR screening test.
我们想要验证这样一个假设,即伴有语言障碍(LI)的神经精神障碍(NPD)是比不伴有 LI 的 NPD 更为严重的变异型,且这种变异型可以通过非言语重复(NWR)任务轻松识别。因此,我们测试了 56 名(平均年龄 7.6 岁,范围 6.1-9.5 岁)儿童,他们分为三组:仅伴有 LI 的一组(n=8)、仅伴有 NPD 的一组(n=16)和同时伴有 LI 和 NPD 的一组(n=32)。我们使用了瑞典 NWR 测试、真实单词重复测试和 WISC-III 的言语理解和不受干扰能力因子。所有三组在 NWR 和真实单词重复方面都比正常组困难,但组内差异相当大。仅伴有 NPD 的一组在 NWR 和真实单词重复方面表现最好,但令人惊讶的是,他们从未被认为有语言问题。伴有 LI 的 NPD 始终得分最低。在这三组中,只有伴有 LI 的 NPD 在言语理解和不受干扰能力方面的得分低于正常范围。NWR 与不受干扰能力和言语理解之间存在显著相关性,这表明 NWR 测试的结果不佳可能不仅仅是言语和语言障碍的“干净”衡量标准,还涉及到其他神经心理结构,包括执行功能障碍。总之,该研究证实了这样一个假设,即伴有 LI 的 NPD 构成了 NPD 的一种更为严重的变异型,且这种变异型可以通过快速、简单的 NWR 筛查测试轻松识别。