Standaert Baudouin, Parez Nathalie, Tehard Bertrand, Colin Xavier, Detournay Bruno
GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals, Rixensart, Belgium.
Appl Health Econ Health Policy. 2008;6(4):199-216. doi: 10.1007/BF03256134.
It is estimated that annually 300 000 cases of rotavirus-induced gastroenteritis (RVGE) occur in children aged up to 5 years in France. A two-dose vaccine against rotavirus infection (RIX4414; Rotarix, GlaxoSmithKline), has been shown to be highly effective against severe RVGE.
This study evaluated the cost effectiveness of general vaccination against rotavirus using RIX4414 in France.
A Markov model simulated RVGE events and the associated outcomes and costs relating to general vaccination of infants against rotavirus infection using RIX4414 (Rotarix) in a birth cohort of children aged up to 5 years in France with a combined adjustment for age distribution with the seasonality of the infection. Costs and outcomes were estimated from a limited societal perspective, including direct medical costs paid out of pocket or by third-party payers, as well as the proportion of direct medical costs reimbursed by the health authorities. Indirect costs were not included in the base-case analysis. The primary outcome measure was the incremental cost per QALY.
Vaccination with RIX4414 incurred an incremental cost of 44 583 Euro per QALY at a public price of 57 Euro per vaccine dose. Univariate sensitivity analyses showed that the parameters with the largest influence on the results were the transition probabilities of severe diarrhoea, seeking medical advice and emergency visits, utility scores of diarrhoea (mild) in children and infants, and the discount rate for benefits. Probabilistic multivariate sensitivity analysis confirmed these results. The acceptability curve indicated that 94% of the results were under an informal threshold of 50 000 Euro per QALY. Comparing our results with those of a recently published study using pooled data for two rotavirus vaccine products in France, the main differences are explained by differences in model structure and in data input values. They include a different age distribution of the infection, shorter duration of the at-risk period (3 years instead of 5 years), different vaccine efficacy, different unit cost data, different disease duration, and different disutility values for the health states in the model. There is a need for agreed standards to improve comparability of results from different studies.
The results demonstrate that a generalized vaccination strategy with RIX4414 would be cost effective in France from a limited societal perspective, depending on the baseline assumptions for disease progression and on utility scores selected.
据估计,法国每年有30万例5岁及以下儿童感染轮状病毒引起的肠胃炎(RVGE)。一种针对轮状病毒感染的两剂疫苗(RIX4414;Rotarix,葛兰素史克公司)已被证明对严重RVGE非常有效。
本研究评估了在法国使用RIX4414进行轮状病毒普遍疫苗接种的成本效益。
一个马尔可夫模型模拟了RVGE事件以及与法国5岁及以下儿童出生队列中使用RIX4414(Rotarix)对婴儿进行轮状病毒感染普遍疫苗接种相关的结果和成本,并结合了年龄分布与感染季节性的调整。成本和结果是从有限的社会角度估计的,包括自付或由第三方支付的直接医疗费用,以及卫生当局报销的直接医疗费用比例。间接成本未纳入基础案例分析。主要结果指标是每获得一个质量调整生命年(QALY)的增量成本。
以每剂疫苗57欧元的公共价格,使用RIX4414进行疫苗接种每获得一个QALY产生的增量成本为44583欧元。单因素敏感性分析表明,对结果影响最大的参数是严重腹泻、寻求医疗建议和急诊就诊的转移概率、儿童和婴儿(轻度)腹泻的效用评分以及效益的贴现率。概率多因素敏感性分析证实了这些结果。可接受性曲线表明,94%的结果低于每QALY 50000欧元的非正式阈值。将我们的结果与最近发表的一项使用法国两种轮状病毒疫苗产品汇总数据的研究结果进行比较,主要差异可由模型结构和数据输入值的差异来解释。它们包括感染的年龄分布不同、风险期持续时间较短(3年而非5年)、疫苗效力不同、单位成本数据不同、疾病持续时间不同以及模型中健康状态的负效用值不同。需要商定标准以提高不同研究结果的可比性。
结果表明,从有限的社会角度来看,根据疾病进展的基线假设和所选的效用评分,在法国采用RIX4414进行普遍疫苗接种策略将具有成本效益。