Reyes-García Victoria, Molina Jose Luis, McDade Thomas W, Tanner Susan N, Huanca Tomas, Leonard William R
ICREA and Institut de Ciència i Tecnologia Ambientals, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, 08193 Bellatera, Barcelona, Spain.
Soc Sci Med. 2009 Aug;69(4):571-8. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2009.05.039. Epub 2009 Jun 18.
Research on the social determinants of health has highlighted (a) the adverse effects of social inequality on individual health and (b) the association between individual social rank and health. In this paper, we contribute to the growing literature on the health consequences of social inequalities by assessing the association between village level inequality in social rank, a form of non-material inequality, and indicators of nutritional status. We use quantitative survey information from 289 men (18+ years of age) from a society of forager-farmers in the Bolivian Amazon (Tsimane'). We construct village level measures of non-material inequality by using individual measures of men's positions in the village hierarchy according to prestige (or freely conferred deference) and dominance (or social rank obtained through power). We find that village inequality in dominance, but not village inequality in prestige, is associated with short-term indices of individual nutritional status. Doubling the coefficient of variation of dominance in a village would be associated to a 6.7% lower BMI, a 7.9% smaller mid-arm circumference, and a 27.1% smaller sum of four skin folds of men in the village. We also find that once we decouple individual social rank based on dominance from individual social rank based on prestige, only prestige-based social rank is associated with nutritional status. Potential explanations for our findings relate to the differential forms of resource access derived from the two forms of social hierarchies and to the social and psychological benefits associated with prestige versus the social costs and psychological stress generated by dominance.
(a)社会不平等对个人健康的不利影响;(b)个人社会地位与健康之间的关联。在本文中,我们通过评估社会地位的村级不平等(一种非物质不平等形式)与营养状况指标之间的关联,为关于社会不平等对健康影响的不断增长的文献做出贡献。我们使用了来自玻利维亚亚马逊地区(齐曼人)一个觅食 - 农耕社会的289名男性(18岁及以上)的定量调查信息。我们根据威望(或自由给予的尊重)和主导地位(或通过权力获得的社会地位),利用男性在村庄等级制度中的个人地位衡量指标,构建了村级非物质不平等的衡量指标。我们发现,主导地位的村级不平等而非威望的村级不平等与个人营养状况的短期指标相关。将一个村庄中主导地位的变异系数翻倍,将与该村男性的体重指数降低6.7%、上臂围减小7.9%以及四处皮肤褶厚度总和减小27.1%相关。我们还发现,一旦我们将基于主导地位的个人社会地位与基于威望的个人社会地位分开,只有基于威望的社会地位与营养状况相关。对我们研究结果的潜在解释涉及从两种社会等级制度中获得的资源获取的不同形式,以及与威望相关的社会和心理益处与主导地位产生的社会成本和心理压力之间的关系。