针对机构养老老年人压力性溃疡治疗的疾病特异性营养支持与标准营养支持:一项随机对照试验。
Disease-specific, versus standard, nutritional support for the treatment of pressure ulcers in institutionalized older adults: a randomized controlled trial.
作者信息
Cereda Emanuele, Gini Anna, Pedrolli Carlo, Vanotti Alfredo
机构信息
International Center for the Assessment of Nutritional Status, University of Milan, Milan, Italy.
出版信息
J Am Geriatr Soc. 2009 Aug;57(8):1395-402. doi: 10.1111/j.1532-5415.2009.02351.x. Epub 2009 Jun 25.
OBJECTIVES
To investigate whether a disease-specific nutritional approach is more beneficial than a standard dietary approach to the healing of pressure ulcers (PUs) in institutionalized elderly patients.
DESIGN
Twelve-week follow-up randomized controlled trial (RCT).
SETTING
Four long-term care facilities in the province of Como, Italy.
PARTICIPANTS
Twenty-eight elderly subjects with Stage II, III, and IV PUs of recent onset (<1-month history).
INTERVENTION
All 28 patients received 30 kcal/kg per day nutritional support; of these, 15 received standard nutrition (hospital diet or standard enteral formula; 16% calories from protein), whereas 13 were administered a disease-specific nutrition treatment consisting of the standard diet plus a 400-mL oral supplement or specific enteral formula enriched with protein (20% of the total calories), arginine, zinc, and vitamin C (P<.001 for all nutrients vs control).
MEASUREMENTS
Ulcer healing was evaluated using the Pressure Ulcer Scale for Healing (PUSH; 0=complete healing, 17=greatest severity) tool and area measurement (mm(2) and %).
RESULTS
The sampled groups were well matched for age, sex, nutritional status, oral intake, type of feeding, and ulcer severity. After 12 weeks, both groups showed significant improvement (P<.001). The treatment produced a higher rate of healing, the PUSH score revealing a significant difference at Week 12 (-6.1+/-2.7 vs -3.3+/-2.4; P<.05) and the reduction in ulcer surface area significantly higher in the treated patients already by Week 8 (-1,140.9+/-669.2 mm(2) vs -571.7+/-391.3 mm(2); P<.05 and approximately 57% vs approximately 33%; P<.02).
CONCLUSION
The rate of PU healing appears to accelerate when a nutrition formula enriched with protein, arginine, zinc, and vitamin C is administered, making such a formula preferable to a standardized one, but the present data require further confirmation by high-quality RCTs conducted on a larger scale.
目的
探讨针对特定疾病的营养方案是否比标准饮食方案对机构养老的老年患者压力性溃疡(PU)的愈合更有益。
设计
为期12周的随访随机对照试验(RCT)。
地点
意大利科莫省的四家长期护理机构。
参与者
28名近期发生(病史<1个月)的II期、III期和IV期PU老年患者。
干预措施
所有28例患者均接受每日30千卡/千克的营养支持;其中15例接受标准营养(医院饮食或标准肠内配方;蛋白质提供16%的热量),而13例接受针对特定疾病的营养治疗,包括标准饮食加400毫升口服补充剂或富含蛋白质(占总热量的20%)、精氨酸、锌和维生素C的特定肠内配方(所有营养素与对照组相比,P<0.001)。
测量指标
使用压力性溃疡愈合量表(PUSH;0=完全愈合,17=最严重)工具和面积测量(平方毫米和百分比)评估溃疡愈合情况。
结果
抽样组在年龄、性别、营养状况、口服摄入量、喂养方式和溃疡严重程度方面匹配良好。12周后,两组均有显著改善(P<0.001)。治疗组的愈合率更高,PUSH评分在第12周时显示出显著差异(-6.1±2.7对-3.3±2.4;P<0.05),并且在第8周时治疗组患者的溃疡表面积减少明显更高(-1140.9±669.2平方毫米对-571.7±391.3平方毫米;P<0.05,约57%对约33%;P<0.02)。
结论
给予富含蛋白质、精氨酸、锌和维生素C的营养配方时,PU的愈合速度似乎会加快,使得这种配方比标准化配方更可取,但目前的数据需要通过更大规模的高质量RCT进一步证实。