Saravane D, Feve B, Frances Y, Corruble E, Lancon C, Chanson P, Maison P, Terra J-L, Azorin J-M
Service des spécialités, l'Association nationale pour la promotion des soins somatiques en santé mentale, EPS Ville-Evrard, 202, avenue Jean-Jaurès, 93332 Neuilly-sur-Marne cedex, France.
Encephale. 2009 Sep;35(4):330-9. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2008.10.014. Epub 2009 Jul 9.
Having a mental illness has been and remains even now, a strong barrier to effective medical care. Most mental illness, such as schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and depression are associated with undue medical morbidity and mortality. It represents a major health problem, with a 15 to 30 year shorter lifetime compared with the general population.
Based these facts, a workshop was convened by a panel of specialists: psychiatrists, endocrinologists, cardiologists, internists, and pharmacologists from some French hospitals to review the information relating to the comorbidity and mortality among the patients with severe mental illness, the risks with antipsychotic treatment for the development of metabolic disorders and finally cardiovascular disease. The French experts strongly agreed on these points: that the patients with severe mental illness have a higher rate of preventable risk factors such as smoking, addiction, poor diet, lack of exercise; the recognition and management of morbidity are made more difficult by barriers related to patients, the illness, the attitudes of medical practitioners, and the structure of healthcare delivery services; and improved detection and treatment of comorbidity medical illness in people with severe mental illness will have significant benefits for their psychosocial functioning and overall quality of life. GUIDELINES FOR INITIATING ANTIPSYCHOTIC THERAPY: Based on these elements, the French experts propose guidelines for practising psychiatrists when initiating and maintaining therapy with antipsychotic compounds. The aim of the guidelines is practical and concerns the detection of medical illness at the first episode of mental illness, management of comorbidity with other specialists, family practitioner and follow-up with some key points. The guidelines are divided into two major parts. The first part provides: a review of mortality and comorbidity of patients with severe mental illness: the increased morbidity and mortality are primarily due to premature cardiovascular disease (myocardial infarction, stroke...).The cardiovascular events are strongly linked to non modifiable risk factors such as age, gender, personal and/or family history, but also to crucial modifiable risk factors, such as overweight and obesity, dyslipidemia, diabetes, hypertension and smoking. Although these classical risk factors exist in the general population, epidemiological studies suggest that patients with severe mental illness have an increased prevalence of these risk factors. The causes of increased metabolic and cardiovascular risk in this population are strongly related to poverty and limited access to medical care, but also to the use of psychotropic medication. A review of major published consensus guidelines for metabolic monitoring of patients treated with antipsychotic medication that have recommended stringent monitoring of metabolic status and cardiovascular risk factors in psychiatric patients receiving antipsychotic drugs. There have been six attempts, all published between 2004 and 2005: Mount Sinai, Australia, ADA-APA, Belgium, United Kingdom, Canada. Each guideline had specific, somewhat discordant, recommendations about which patients and drugs should be monitored. However, there was agreement on the importance of baseline monitoring and follow-up for the first three to four months of treatment, with subsequent ongoing reevaluation. There was agreement on the utility of the following tests and measures: weight and height, waist circumference, blood pressure, fasting plasma glucose, fasting lipid profile. In the second part, the French experts propose guidelines for practising psychiatrists when initiating and maintaining therapy with antipsychotic drugs: the first goal is identification of risk factors for development of metabolic and cardiovascular disorders: non modifiable risk factors: these include: increasing age, gender (increased rates of obesity, diabetes and metabolic syndrome are observed in female patients treated with antipsychotic drugs), personal and family history of obesity, diabetes, heart disease, ethnicity as we know that there are increased rates of diabetes, metabolic syndrome and coronary heart disease in patients of non European ethnicity, especially among South Asian, Hispanic, and Native American people. Modifiable risk factors: these include: obesity, visceral obesity, smoking, physical inactivity, and bad diet habits. Then the expert's panel focussed on all the components of the initial visit such as: family and medical history; baseline weight and BMI should be measured for all patients. Body mass index can be calculated by dividing weight (in kilograms) by height (in meters) squared; visceral obesity measured by waist circumference; blood pressure; fasting plasma glucose; fasting lipid profiles. These are the basic measures and laboratory examinations to do when initiating an antipsychotic treatment. ECG: several of the antipsychotic medications, typical and atypical, have been shown to prolong the QTc interval on the ECG. Prolongation of the QTc interval is of potential concern since the patient may be at risk for wave burst arrhythmia, a potentially serious ventricular arrhythmia. A QTc interval greater than 500 ms places the patient at a significantly increased risk for serious arrhythmia. QTc prolongation has been reported with varying incidence and degrees of severity. The atypical antipsychotics can also cause other cardiovascular adverse effects with, for example, orthostatic hypotension. Risk factors for cardiovascular adverse effects with antipsychotics include: known cardiovascular disease, electrolyte disorders, such as hypokaliemia, hypomagnesaemia, genetic characteristics, increasing age, female gender, autonomic dysfunction, high doses of antipsychotics, the use of interacting drugs, and psychiatric illness itself. In any patient with pre-existing cardiac disease, a pre-treatment ECG with routine follow-up is recommended.
Patients on antipsychotic drugs should undergo regular testing of blood sugar, lipid profile, as well as body weight, waist circumference and blood pressure, with recommended time intervals between measures. Clinicians should track the effects of treatment on physical and biological parameters, and should facilitate access to appropriate medical care. In order to prevent or limit possible side effects, information must be given to the patient and his family on the cardiovascular and metabolic risks. The cost-effectiveness of implementing these recommendations is considerable: the costs of laboratory tests and additional equipment costs (such as scales, tape measures, and blood pressure devices) are modest. The issue of responsibility for monitoring for metabolic abnormalities is much debated. However, with the prescription of antipsychotic drugs comes the responsibility for monitoring potential drug-induced metabolic abnormalities. The onset of metabolic disorders will imply specific treatments. A coordinated action of psychiatrists, general practitioners, endocrinologists, cardiologists, nurses, dieticians, and of the family is certainly a key determinant to ensure the optimal care of these patients.
患有精神疾病一直是,即使在现在仍然是有效医疗护理的强大障碍。大多数精神疾病,如精神分裂症、双相情感障碍和抑郁症,都与过度的医疗发病率和死亡率相关。它代表了一个重大的健康问题,与普通人群相比,寿命缩短15至30年。
基于这些事实,由一组专家召开了一次研讨会,这些专家包括来自法国一些医院的精神科医生、内分泌学家、心脏病学家、内科医生和药理学家,以审查与严重精神疾病患者的共病和死亡率、抗精神病药物治疗引发代谢紊乱进而引发心血管疾病的风险相关的信息。法国专家在以下几点上强烈达成共识:严重精神疾病患者有更高比例的可预防风险因素,如吸烟、成瘾、不良饮食、缺乏运动;与患者、疾病、医生态度以及医疗服务提供结构相关的障碍使得对发病率的识别和管理更加困难;改善对严重精神疾病患者共病的检测和治疗将对他们的心理社会功能和整体生活质量产生重大益处。抗精神病治疗启动指南:基于这些因素,法国专家为执业精神科医生在启动和维持抗精神病药物治疗时提出指南。该指南的目的是实用的,涉及在精神疾病首发时对医疗疾病的检测、与其他专科医生和家庭医生对共病的管理以及一些关键点的随访。该指南分为两个主要部分。第一部分提供:对严重精神疾病患者死亡率和共病情况的综述:发病率和死亡率增加主要是由于心血管疾病过早发作(心肌梗死、中风等)。心血管事件与不可改变的风险因素如年龄、性别、个人和/或家族病史密切相关,但也与关键的可改变风险因素如超重和肥胖、血脂异常、糖尿病、高血压和吸烟密切相关。虽然这些经典风险因素在普通人群中也存在,但流行病学研究表明严重精神疾病患者这些风险因素的患病率更高。该人群代谢和心血管风险增加的原因与贫困和获得医疗护理的机会有限密切相关,但也与使用精神药物有关。对已发表的关于接受抗精神病药物治疗患者代谢监测的主要共识指南的综述,这些指南建议对接受抗精神病药物治疗的精神病患者的代谢状况和心血管风险因素进行严格监测。在2004年至2005年期间共有六项尝试:西奈山、澳大利亚、美国糖尿病协会 - 美国精神病学协会、比利时、英国、加拿大。每个指南对于应监测哪些患者和药物都有具体的、有些不一致的建议。然而,对于治疗前三个月至四个月的基线监测和随访以及随后的持续重新评估的重要性达成了共识。对于以下测试和措施的效用达成了共识:体重和身高、腰围、血压、空腹血糖、空腹血脂谱。在第二部分中,法国专家为执业精神科医生在启动和维持抗精神病药物治疗时提出指南:首要目标是识别代谢和心血管疾病发展的风险因素:不可改变的风险因素:这些包括:年龄增长、性别(在接受抗精神病药物治疗的女性患者中观察到肥胖、糖尿病和代谢综合征的发生率增加)、肥胖、糖尿病、心脏病的个人和家族病史、种族,因为我们知道非欧洲种族的患者,特别是南亚、西班牙裔和美洲原住民中糖尿病、代谢综合征和冠心病的发生率增加。可改变的风险因素:这些包括:肥胖、内脏肥胖、吸烟、身体活动不足和不良饮食习惯。然后专家小组关注初次就诊的所有组成部分,如:家族和病史;应为所有患者测量基线体重和体重指数。体重指数可以通过体重(千克)除以身高(米)的平方来计算;通过腰围测量内脏肥胖;血压;空腹血糖;空腹血脂谱。这些是启动抗精神病治疗时要进行的基本测量和实验室检查。心电图:几种抗精神病药物,无论是典型的还是非典型的,都已被证明会延长心电图上的QTc间期。QTc间期延长是一个潜在的问题,因为患者可能有发生波阵面心律失常的风险,这是一种潜在的严重室性心律失常。QTc间期大于500毫秒会使患者发生严重心律失常的风险显著增加。QTc延长的发生率和严重程度各不相同。非典型抗精神病药物还可能引起其他心血管不良反应,例如体位性低血压。抗精神病药物心血管不良反应的风险因素包括:已知的心血管疾病、电解质紊乱,如低钾血症、低镁血症、遗传特征、年龄增长、女性性别、自主神经功能障碍、高剂量抗精神病药物、使用相互作用药物以及精神疾病本身。对于任何患有既往心脏病的患者,建议进行治疗前心电图检查并进行常规随访。
服用抗精神病药物的患者应定期进行血糖、血脂谱以及体重、腰围和血压的检测,并建议在各项检测之间有规定的时间间隔。临床医生应跟踪治疗对身体和生物学参数的影响,并应促进患者获得适当的医疗护理。为了预防或限制可能的副作用,必须向患者及其家属告知心血管和代谢风险。实施这些建议的成本效益相当可观:实验室检测成本和额外设备成本(如秤、卷尺和血压计)适中。关于监测代谢异常责任的问题存在很多争议。然而,开具抗精神病药物处方就意味着有责任监测潜在的药物引起的代谢异常。代谢紊乱的发生将意味着需要特定的治疗。精神科医生、全科医生、内分泌学家、心脏病学家、护士、营养师以及患者家属的协同行动肯定是确保对这些患者进行最佳护理的关键决定因素。