Jang Chul Ho, Park Haekyun, Choi Cheol Hee, Cho Yong Bum, Park Il Yong
Department of Otolaryngology, Chonnam National Medical School, Gwangju, South Korea.
Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol. 2010 Jan;74(1):71-4. doi: 10.1016/j.ijporl.2009.10.020. Epub 2009 Nov 20.
Recently experimental trials have demonstrated that nebulized natural surfactant is effective in the treatment of experimental otitis media with effusion (OME). Two methodologically incomplete studies using animal models of induced OME have reported that nebulized surfactant can improve Eustachian tube function. There have been no reports that investigated the efficacy of the nebulized surfactant for OME using analysis of tympanic membrane vibration. In this study, we evaluated the therapeutic effect of nebulized natural surfactant by investigation of tympanic membrane vibration.
The guinea pigs (n=20) were divided into three groups. Four normal guinea pigs without any treatment were used as normal controls. Sixteen pigs were given experimental OME in both ear and then divided into two groups. The OME model of guinea pig was created by transbullar injection 10 microl of lipopolysaccharide in saline. Experimental group 1 (n=8) was nebulized phosphate buffered saline (PBS). Experimental group 2 (n=8) was nebulized natural bovine surfactant. The transnasal nebulization was repeated for 7 days in both experimental groups. On the 8th day, both experimental groups and normal control group were measured the tympanic membrane vibration by laser Doppler vibrometer (LDV), and additionally histopathologic observation was performed by scanning electron microscope (SEM).
The TM vibration velocity in nebulized PBS group showed significantly reduced mainly at low frequencies. However, nebulized natural surfactant group recovered the reduction of tympanic membrane vibration. In nebulized PBS group, SEM showed severe thickened subepithelial layer and hyperplasia of gland structure. However, in nebulized natural surfactant group, SEM showed the reduced the thickness of subepithelial layer and the loss of glandular hyperplasia.
From our results, the nebulized natural surfactant is postulated to be effective in the treatment of intractable OME in animal model. The measurement of tympanic membrane vibration for analysis of middle ear mechanics was significantly corresponding to the middle ear mucosal changes. LDV is a useful tool for investigate the therapeutic effect of nebulized surfactant in experimental OME. With supporting clinical studies, nebulization of natural surfactant may become noninvasive treatment of OME in future.
最近的实验性试验表明,雾化天然表面活性剂在治疗实验性分泌性中耳炎(OME)方面是有效的。两项使用诱导性OME动物模型的方法学不完整的研究报告称,雾化表面活性剂可以改善咽鼓管功能。尚无研究通过分析鼓膜振动来探究雾化表面活性剂治疗OME的疗效。在本研究中,我们通过研究鼓膜振动来评估雾化天然表面活性剂的治疗效果。
将20只豚鼠分为三组。四只未经任何处理的正常豚鼠作为正常对照组。16只豚鼠双耳诱发实验性OME,然后分为两组。通过经鼓室注射10微升盐水中的脂多糖建立豚鼠OME模型。实验组1(n = 8)雾化磷酸缓冲盐水(PBS)。实验组2(n = 8)雾化天然牛表面活性剂。两个实验组均重复经鼻雾化7天。在第8天,使用激光多普勒振动计(LDV)测量两个实验组和正常对照组的鼓膜振动,并通过扫描电子显微镜(SEM)进行额外的组织病理学观察。
雾化PBS组的鼓膜振动速度主要在低频时显著降低。然而,雾化天然表面活性剂组恢复了鼓膜振动的降低。在雾化PBS组中,SEM显示上皮下严重增厚和腺体结构增生。然而,在雾化天然表面活性剂组中,SEM显示上皮下层厚度减小和腺体增生消失。
根据我们的结果,推测雾化天然表面活性剂在动物模型中治疗顽固性OME有效。测量鼓膜振动以分析中耳力学与中耳黏膜变化显著相关。LDV是研究雾化表面活性剂在实验性OME中治疗效果的有用工具。随着支持性临床研究的开展,天然表面活性剂雾化可能在未来成为OME的无创治疗方法。