Washington State Department of Ecology, N. 4601 Monroe, Spokane, WA 99205-1295, USA.
Environ Res. 2010 Feb;110(2):169-77. doi: 10.1016/j.envres.2009.10.013. Epub 2009 Nov 22.
Historical operations at the Hanford Site (Washington State, USA) have released a wide array of non-radionuclide and radionuclide contaminants into the environment. As a result of stakeholder concerns, Native American exposure scenarios have been integrated into Hanford risk assessments. Because its contribution to radiological risk to Native Americans is culturally and geographically specific but quantitatively uncertain, a fish and wildlife ingestion pathway was examined in this study. Adult consumption rates were derived from 20 Native American scenarios (based on 12 studies) at Hanford, and tissue concentrations of key radionuclides in fish, game birds, and game mammals were compiled from the Hanford Environmental Information System (HEIS) database for a recent time interval (1995-2007) during the post-operational period. It was assumed that skeletal muscle comprised 90% of intake, while other tissues accounted for the remainder. Acknowledging data gaps, median concentrations of eight radionuclides (i.e., Co-60, Cs-137, Sr-90, Tc-99, U-234, U-238, Pu-238, and Pu-239/240) in skeletal muscle and other tissues were below 0.01 and 1 pCi/g wet wt, respectively. These radionuclide concentrations were not significantly different (Bonferroni P>0.05) on and off the Hanford Site. Despite no observed difference between onsite and offsite tissue concentrations, radiation dose and risk were calculated for the fish and wildlife ingestion pathway using onsite data. With median consumption rates and radionuclide tissue concentrations, skeletal muscle provided 42% of the dose, while other tissues (primarily bone and carcass) accounted for 58%. In terms of biota, fish ingestion was the largest contributor to dose (64%). Among radionuclides, Sr-90 was dominant, accounting for 47% of the dose. At median intake and radionuclide levels, estimated annual dose (0.36 mrem/yr) was below a dose limit of 15 mrem/yr recommended by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA), as well as below a dose limit of 100 mrem/yr proposed by the International Commission on Radiation Protection (ICRP). Similarly, lifetime cancer risk (1.7E-5), calculated with median inputs, was below risk levels corresponding to these dose limits. However, our dose and risk estimates apply to only one pathway within a multidimensional exposure scenario for Native Americans. On the other hand, radiation dose and risk corresponding to onsite tissue concentrations were not significantly different from those corresponding to offsite (background) concentrations. Recognizing uncertainties in exposure and toxicity assessments, our results may facilitate informed decision making and optimize resource allocation within a risk assessment framework at the Hanford Site.
美国华盛顿州汉福德地区的历史作业已经向环境中释放了大量的非放射性核素和放射性核素污染物。由于利益相关者的担忧,已经将美国原住民的暴露情况纳入了汉福德风险评估中。由于其对美国原住民的放射性风险的贡献在文化和地理上是特定的,但在数量上是不确定的,因此在本研究中检查了鱼类和野生动物的摄入途径。从汉福德的 20 个美国原住民情景(基于 12 项研究)中得出了成年人的消费率,并且从汉福德环境信息系统(HEIS)数据库中编译了鱼类、猎禽和猎兽组织中关键放射性核素的浓度,用于最近的时间段(1995-2007 年)在操作后期。假设骨骼肌肉占摄入量的 90%,而其他组织占其余部分。鉴于数据空白,骨骼肌肉和其他组织中八种放射性核素(即 Co-60、Cs-137、Sr-90、Tc-99、U-234、U-238、Pu-238 和 Pu-239/240)的中位数浓度分别低于 0.01 和 1 pCi/g 湿重。这些放射性核素浓度在汉福德地区内外没有明显差异(Bonferroni P>0.05)。尽管现场和场外组织浓度之间没有观察到差异,但仍使用现场数据计算了鱼类和野生动物摄入途径的辐射剂量和风险。使用中位数消费率和放射性核素组织浓度,骨骼肌肉提供了 42%的剂量,而其他组织(主要是骨骼和尸体)则占 58%。就生物群而言,鱼类摄食是剂量的最大贡献者(64%)。在放射性核素中,Sr-90 占主导地位,占剂量的 47%。在中等摄入量和放射性核素水平下,估计的年剂量(0.36 mrem/yr)低于美国环境保护署(USEPA)推荐的 15 mrem/yr 剂量限值,也低于国际辐射防护委员会(ICRP)建议的 100 mrem/yr 剂量限值。同样,使用中位数输入计算出的终生癌症风险(1.7E-5)也低于这些剂量限值对应的风险水平。然而,我们的剂量和风险估计仅适用于美国原住民多维暴露情景中的一个途径。另一方面,现场组织浓度对应的辐射剂量和风险与场外(背景)浓度对应的辐射剂量和风险没有显著差异。认识到暴露和毒性评估中的不确定性,我们的结果可能有助于在汉福德地区的风险评估框架内做出明智的决策并优化资源分配。