Department of Pediatric Dentistry, University of Florida College of Dentistry, P.O. Box 100426, Gainesville, FL 32610, USA.
J Dent Educ. 2009 Dec;73(12):1366-71.
Students' acceptability scores of pediatric dental behavior guidance techniques and clinical situations were measured with visual analog scales in a four-year dental curriculum. At the end of the curriculum, the highest scores were for positive reinforcement (94.7+/-4.7), use of nitrous oxide (93.1+/-7.5), stimulating the child's imagination (90.4+/-11.1), tell-show-do (90.4+/-10.0), distraction (89.7+/-11.6), use of euphemisms (88.3+/-14.4), voice control (86.2+/-12.4), and promising a toy (83.6+/-17.7). The lowest scores were for showing a needle (23.1+/-20.9), treatment without local anesthetic (25.4+/-24.2), parent talking with the child during treatment (35.3+/-22.4), hand over mouth (37.1+/-25.4), dentist/assistant being quiet (38.5+/-25.3), and not allowing the child to speak (38.6+/-26.8). Comparison of scores after only didactic education versus after clinical plus didactic education indicated a significant increase in acceptability for general anesthesia and significant decreases for situations involving the parent in the clinic. Ranking of scores before and after the dental curriculum showed the largest change in ranking for general anesthesia (+10), telling that the treatment may involve pain (-9), parent's presence (-8) or talking with the child during treatment (-10), and use of nitrous oxide (+7). Dental education has the potential to shape students' perceptions about pediatric dental behavior guidance.
在四年制牙科课程中,学生们通过视觉模拟评分法对儿科牙科行为指导技术和临床情况的可接受性进行了评分。在课程结束时,得分最高的是正强化(94.7+/-4.7)、使用笑气(93.1+/-7.5)、激发孩子想象力(90.4+/-11.1)、说-看-做(90.4+/-10.0)、分散注意力(89.7+/-11.6)、使用委婉语(88.3+/-14.4)、语音控制(86.2+/-12.4)和承诺玩具(83.6+/-17.7)。得分最低的是展示针头(23.1+/-20.9)、无局部麻醉下治疗(25.4+/-24.2)、治疗期间家长与孩子交谈(35.3+/-22.4)、手放嘴上(37.1+/-25.4)、牙医/助手保持安静(38.5+/-25.3)和不让孩子说话(38.6+/-26.8)。仅在理论教育后与理论加临床教育后进行评分比较表明,全身麻醉的可接受性显著增加,而涉及家长在诊所的情况则显著减少。在牙科课程前后对评分进行排名,全身麻醉的排名变化最大(+10),其次是告知治疗可能涉及疼痛(-9)、家长在场(-8)或在治疗期间与孩子交谈(-10),以及使用笑气(+7)。牙科教育有可能影响学生对儿科牙科行为指导的看法。