Houston Department of Health and Human Services, Community Health Statistics, Houston, TX 77054, USA.
J Community Health. 2010 Apr;35(2):135-41. doi: 10.1007/s10900-009-9208-y.
Self-reported health, a widely used measure of general health status in population studies, can be affected by certain demographic variables such as gender, race/ethnicity and education. This cross-sectional assessment of the current health status of older adult residents was conducted in an inner-city Houston neighborhood in May, 2007. A survey instrument, with questions on chronic disease prevalence, health limitations/functional status, self-reported subjective health status in addition to demographic data on households was administered to a systematic random sample of residents. Older adults (>60 years of age) were interviewed (weighted N = 127) at their homes by trained interviewers. The results indicated that these residents, with low literacy levels, low household income and a high prevalence of frequently reported chronic diseases (hypertension, diabetes and arthritis) also reported non-participation in community activities, volunteerism and activities centered on organized religion, thus, potentially placing them at risk for social isolation. Women reported poorer self-reported health and appeared to fare worse in all health limitation indicators and reported greater structural barriers in involvement with their community. Blacks reported worse health outcomes on all indicators than other sub-groups, an indication that skills training in chronic disease self-management and in actively eliciting support from various sources may be beneficial for this group. Therefore, the use of self-reported health with a broad brush as an indicator of "true" population health status is not advisable. Sufficient consideration should be given to the racial/ethnic and gender differences and these should be accounted for.
自报健康状况是人群研究中广泛用于衡量总体健康状况的指标,但它可能会受到某些人口统计学变量的影响,例如性别、种族/民族和教育程度。本研究于 2007 年 5 月在休斯顿市的一个内城区进行,对该城区老年居民的当前健康状况进行了横断面评估。调查工具包含有关慢性病患病率、健康限制/功能状态、自报主观健康状况以及家庭人口统计学数据的问题,对居民进行了系统随机抽样调查。由经过培训的访谈员在老年人(>60 岁)的家中对他们进行访谈(加权 N=127)。结果表明,这些文化程度低、家庭收入低且经常报告患有慢性病(高血压、糖尿病和关节炎)的居民还报告称不参与社区活动、志愿服务和以有组织宗教为中心的活动,因此他们可能面临社交孤立的风险。女性报告的自报健康状况较差,在所有健康限制指标上的表现都较差,并且在参与社区活动方面面临更大的结构性障碍。黑人在所有指标上的健康结果都比其他亚组差,这表明对慢性病自我管理和积极从各种来源获取支持的技能培训可能对该群体有益。因此,使用自报健康状况作为“真实”人口健康状况的指标并不合适。应充分考虑种族/民族和性别差异,并对其进行考虑。