Department of Paediatric Neurology, The Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, UK.
Epilepsia. 2010 May;51(5):777-82. doi: 10.1111/j.1528-1167.2009.02483.x. Epub 2010 Jan 7.
The 2007 UK National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) guidelines for epilepsy recommend disclosing the risk of sudden unexpected death in epilepsy (SUDEP) to patients. This recommendation is not undertaken routinely, and considerable variation in individual physician practice exists. Literature indicates wariness of causing distress and anxiety, particularly to children/young people and their families through disclosing a nonpreventable risk. There has been no systematic pediatric study examining parent/guardian information needs and beliefs for risk of SUDEP and its impact on seizure management. It is important to first address these concerns before routinely imparting SUDEP information to parents following NICE recommendations.
Two questionnaire surveys: a questionnaire examining the provision by pediatric neurologists of SUDEP information, and questionnaires examining parental beliefs and implications at two time points regarding SUDEP information provided in a leaflet. Participants were included in the study if their child had an established diagnosis of epilepsy. Factors for exclusion were single unprovoked seizure, absence seizures, patients in remission, and active discontinuation of treatment.
The majority (74%) of pediatric neurologists provided SUDEP information only to a select group of children with epilepsy and were uncertain about the effect such information would have upon the parent and child. Conversely, 91% of parents expected the pediatric neurologist to provide SUDEP risk information. The provision of this information did not have a significant immediate and longer-term negative impact.
The majority of parents wanted to know about SUDEP and its associated risks. Whenever possible, SUDEP information should be given by the physician accompanied by an information leaflet.
2007 年英国国家卫生与临床优化研究所(NICE)癫痫指南建议向患者披露癫痫猝死(SUDEP)的风险。但该建议并未得到常规执行,且个体医生的实践存在较大差异。文献表明,医生对通过披露无法预防的风险而引起患者或其家属的痛苦和焦虑存在顾虑,尤其是对儿童/青少年及其家庭。尚未有系统的儿科研究调查父母/监护人对 SUDEP 风险及其对癫痫管理影响的信息需求和信念。在根据 NICE 建议向家长常规提供 SUDEP 信息之前,首先解决这些问题很重要。
进行了两项问卷调查:一项调查了儿科神经科医生提供 SUDEP 信息的情况,另一项调查了在两个时间点通过传单提供 SUDEP 信息时家长的信念和影响。如果其孩子已确诊为癫痫,则将参与者纳入研究。排除标准为单次无诱因发作、失神发作、缓解期患者和正在积极停药的患者。
大多数(74%)儿科神经科医生仅向少数患有癫痫的儿童提供 SUDEP 信息,并且不确定此类信息对父母和孩子会产生什么影响。相反,91%的家长期望儿科神经科医生提供 SUDEP 风险信息。提供这些信息并没有立即产生显著的负面影响,也没有长期的负面影响。
大多数家长希望了解 SUDEP 及其相关风险。只要有可能,就应由医生提供 SUDEP 信息,并附有信息传单。