Liu Ming, Xiang Zhou, Pei Fuxing, Huang Fuguo, Cen Shiqiang, Zhong Gang, Fan Hongsong, Xiao Yumei, Sun Jing, Gao Yu
Department of Orthopedics, State Key Laboratory of Biotherapy, West China Hospital, Sichuan University, Chengdu Sichuan, 610041, PR China.
Zhongguo Xiu Fu Chong Jian Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2010 Jan;24(1):87-93.
To explore the preparing methods in vitro and test the clinical applicability of implantation in vivo of bone marrow stromal stem cells (BMSCs)-biphasic scaffold to repair defects of cartilage and subchondral bone and to compare the differences in repaired outcomes of composite, single biphasic scaffold and rabbits themselves.
The upper chondral phase and the lower osseous phase of the plugs, using poly-lactic-co-glycolic acid (PLGA), hydroxyapatite (HA), and other biomaterials, were fused into carrier scaffold, on which collagen type I (Col I) was coated. The surface and inner structure of biphasic scaffold were observed under scanning electron microscope (SEM). BMSCs was isolated from the bone marrow of tibia and femurs of young New Zealand rabbits using centrifuging and washing, and their morphologies and adherences were observed everyday. Then BMSCs were inoculated on the surface of scaffold to form BMSCs-scaffold composites. Osteochondral defects were surgically created on articular surface of femoral intercondylar of 30 New Zealand rabbits, which were divided into groups A, B and C. In group A, a biphasic osteochondral composite were implanted into defect, BMSCs and biphasic cylindrical porous plug of PLGA-HA-Col I in group B, and group C was used as a control without implant. Specimens were harvested to make macroscopic and histological observations at the 1st, 3rd, 6th, and 9th months after operation respectively; meanwhile immunohistological and micro-computed tomography (micro CT) examinations were performed and graded at the 9th month after operation.
SEM showed an excellent connection of holes in the biphasic scaffold infiltrated by Col I. Optical microscopy and SEM showed a good growth of BMSCs in scaffold without obvious cellular morphological changes and an accumulation in the holes. Macroscopic samples showed a resistant existence of defects of group C within 9 months; the scaffold completely degenerated and chondral-like tissue formed on articular surface with partly collapses and irregular defects in group A; and smoother surface without collapses and approach to normal with texture of new regeneration in group B. There were statistically significant differences in macroscopic results (P < 0.001), group B was superior to group A, and group C was the worst. The micro CT showed good repairs and reconstruction of subchondral bone, with a acceptable integration with newborn chondral-like tissue and host bone in group B. Quantificational analysis of relevant parameters showed no significant differences. Histological results showed inflammations located in defects at the 1st month, new tissue grew into scaffold at the 3rd month; new chondral-like tissue crept on the margin of defects and biphasic scaffold degenerated completely at the 6th month, and lots of collagen formed in subchondral bone with major fibrocartilage on chondral area at the 9th month after surgery in groups A and B. In groups A and B, immunohistological observations were weak positive for Col II and positive for Col I.
Biphasic scaffold implanted in body can induce and accelerate repair of defects of articular cartilages which are mainly filled with fibrocartilage, especially for subchondral bone. Scaffold combined with BMSCs has the best repairing effects 9 months after implantation.
探讨体外制备骨髓基质干细胞(BMSCs)-双相支架并检测其体内植入修复软骨及软骨下骨缺损的临床适用性,比较复合材料、单一双相支架及兔自身修复效果的差异。
采用聚乳酸-乙醇酸共聚物(PLGA)、羟基磷灰石(HA)等生物材料将栓子的上层软骨相和下层骨相融合成载体支架,并在其上包被I型胶原(Col I)。在扫描电子显微镜(SEM)下观察双相支架的表面及内部结构。采用离心洗涤法从幼年新西兰兔的胫骨和股骨骨髓中分离BMSCs,每天观察其形态及贴壁情况。然后将BMSCs接种于支架表面形成BMSCs-支架复合材料。对30只新西兰兔的股骨髁间关节面进行手术制造骨软骨缺损,分为A、B、C组。A组植入双相骨软骨复合材料,B组植入BMSCs及PLGA-HA-Col I双相圆柱形多孔栓子,C组作为未植入的对照组。分别于术后1、3、6、9个月取材进行大体及组织学观察;同时于术后9个月进行免疫组织学及微计算机断层扫描(micro CT)检查并评分。
SEM显示Col I浸润的双相支架内孔连接良好。光学显微镜及SEM显示BMSCs在支架内生长良好,细胞形态无明显改变,在孔内聚集。大体标本显示C组缺损在9个月内持续存在;A组支架完全退变,关节面形成软骨样组织,部分塌陷且有不规则缺损;B组表面较光滑,无塌陷,新生组织质地接近正常。大体结果差异有统计学意义(P < 0.001),B组优于A组,C组最差。micro CT显示B组软骨下骨修复及重建良好,与新生软骨样组织及宿主骨整合良好。相关参数的定量分析无明显差异。组织学结果显示术后1个月缺损处有炎症,3个月新生组织长入支架;6个月新生软骨样组织在缺损边缘爬行,双相支架完全退变,术后9个月A、B组软骨下骨形成大量胶原,软骨区主要为纤维软骨。A、B组免疫组织学观察Col II弱阳性,Col I阳性。
体内植入双相支架可诱导并加速主要由纤维软骨填充的关节软骨缺损的修复,尤其对软骨下骨。支架联合BMSCs植入9个月后修复效果最佳。