Radiology Department, Institute of Neurosciences, Glasgow, Scotland, UK.
Clin Radiol. 2010 Mar;65(3):213-7. doi: 10.1016/j.crad.2009.11.006. Epub 2010 Jan 8.
To compare the efficiency of multidetector computed tomography (MDCT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in the diagnosis of jugular foramen lesions.
The imaging of 15 patients with tumours predominantly occurring at the jugular foramen was retrospectively reviewed, with postoperative pathology data available for 11 patients. MDCT was performed at arterial phase and MRI with standard sequences and contrast enhancement. All imaging was blindly re-reported by an experienced neuroradiologist.
Pathology reported six glomus jugulare tumours and five neuromas, which were all correctly diagnosed using MDCT. A confident diagnosis was also made in the remaining four cases based on the pattern of enhancement. Only glomus tumours enhanced in the arterial phase. Overall, MRI was used to make a confident diagnosis in eight patients. One showed no enhancement and was correctly diagnosed as a neuroma, and seven demonstrated the tumour flow voids characteristic of a glomus tumour. The remaining seven cases all showed a similar enhancement pattern and could not be confidently differentiated between a neuroma or a glomus tumour. MDCT angiography enabled a confident assessment of the jugular vein in all cases, but MRI was inconclusive in a third of cases. Also, in the nine cases of glomus tumour diagnosed using MDCT, an enlarged feeding artery was identified in eight patients.
MDCT is more accurate than MRI in diagnosing glomus tumours, and in particular, neuromas. It also offers valuable preoperative vascular information to the surgeon.
比较多层螺旋 CT(MDCT)和磁共振成像(MRI)在诊断颈静脉孔病变中的效率。
回顾性分析 15 例以颈静脉孔为主的肿瘤患者的影像资料,其中 11 例患者术后有病理学数据。MDCT 在动脉期进行,MRI 采用标准序列和增强检查。所有影像学检查均由一名经验丰富的神经放射科医生进行盲法重新报告。
病理学报告了 6 例颈静脉球瘤和 5 例神经瘤,MDCT 均正确诊断。根据强化模式,其余 4 例也做出了明确诊断。仅颈静脉球瘤在动脉期增强。总体而言,MRI 对 8 例患者做出了明确诊断。1 例未见强化,正确诊断为神经瘤,7 例显示出符合颈静脉球瘤的肿瘤流空效应。其余 7 例均表现出相似的强化模式,无法明确区分神经瘤或颈静脉球瘤。MDCT 血管造影术可在所有病例中对颈静脉进行有信心的评估,但 MRI 在三分之一的病例中结果不确定。此外,在 9 例经 MDCT 诊断为颈静脉球瘤的病例中,8 例患者发现有增大的供血动脉。
MDCT 在诊断颈静脉球瘤,特别是神经瘤方面比 MRI 更准确。它还为外科医生提供了有价值的术前血管信息。