De Decker Steven, Gielen Ingrid M V L, Duchateau Luc, Polis Ingeborgh, Van Bree Henri J J, Van Ham Luc M L
Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Ghent University, Department of Small Animal Medicine and Clinical Biology, Merelbeke, Belgium.
Vet Surg. 2010 Jan;39(1):28-34. doi: 10.1111/j.1532-950X.2009.00559.x.
To evaluate agreement and repeatability of vertebral column measurements using computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).
Retrospective observational study. ANIMALS; Dogs (n=18) with disc associated wobbler syndrome; Dog cadavers (n=3).
Five measurements of the 5th cervical vertebra were performed: vertebral body length (VBL), vertebral canal height (VCH), vertebral body height (VBH), vertebral canal width (VCW), and vertebral body width (VBW). Measurements were performed independently twice by 2 observers. Bland-Altman plots were created to evaluate agreement. Cadaveric vertebrae with soft tissue removed had the same variables and actual dimensions measured.
The largest discrepancy between CT and MRI measurement was for VBL (mean difference+/-SD=1.262 mm+/-1.245; P<.001), with the difference for all the other variables being acceptable. The 1st measurement was significantly higher than the 2nd only for VBL using CT (mean difference=0.476 mm+/-1.120; P=.009), with all other variables having acceptable differences. Mean difference for all measurements between 2 observers was small, except for VBL using CT (mean difference=0.762 mm+/-1.042; P<.001). Only the difference for VBL between CT and cadaver specimens was statistically significant.
Our results suggest high repeatability and good agreement for most vertebral measurements of interest. VBL measurement using CT was considered problematic.
Provided limitations are understood, linear measurements of vertebral dimensions from CT and MRI images can be used clinically.
评估使用计算机断层扫描(CT)和磁共振成像(MRI)测量脊柱的一致性和可重复性。
回顾性观察研究。
患有椎间盘相关摇摆综合征的犬(n = 18);犬尸体(n = 3)。
对第5颈椎进行5项测量:椎体长度(VBL)、椎管高度(VCH)、椎体高度(VBH)、椎管宽度(VCW)和椎体宽度(VBW)。由2名观察者独立进行2次测量。绘制布兰德-奥特曼图以评估一致性。去除软组织的尸体椎骨测量相同变量和实际尺寸。
CT和MRI测量之间最大差异在于VBL(平均差异±标准差 = 1.262 mm±1.245;P <.001),其他所有变量的差异均可接受。仅使用CT测量VBL时,第1次测量显著高于第2次测量(平均差异 = 0.476 mm±1.120;P =.009),其他所有变量的差异均可接受。2名观察者之间所有测量的平均差异较小,但使用CT测量VBL时除外(平均差异 = 0.762 mm±1.042;P <.001)。仅CT与尸体标本之间VBL的差异具有统计学意义。
我们的结果表明,大多数感兴趣的椎体测量具有高可重复性和良好一致性。使用CT测量VBL被认为存在问题。
只要理解其局限性,CT和MRI图像中椎体尺寸的线性测量可用于临床。