Dyke Janet E, Gidman Wendy K, Wilson Sarah E, Becket Gordon
School of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences, University of Central Lancashire, Preston, UK.
Int J Pharm Pract. 2009 Feb;17(1):61-6. doi: 10.1211/ijpp/17.1.0009.
The aims of this study were to determine whether first-year Master of Pharmacy (MPharm) students would engage with an activity similar to pharmacists' continuing professional development, and to explore attitudes surrounding this task.
A paper version of the Royal Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain's electronic template for recording continuing professional development was developed. Students were asked to use this paper version to record the planning, action and evaluation carried out while completing a written assignment. The records were assessed to determine any reflective self-assessment contained in the evaluation section, and whether this reflection related to the specified learning outcome and the planning and action stages. Six focus groups were run, during which the students discussed their reaction to completing these records. The study was carried out during the first semester with first-year undergraduate MPharm students in the School of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences at the University of Central Lancashire in the UK.
It was found that few students appeared to engage fully with the whole recording process. During focus-group sessions competence to self-assess was raised as an issue by students, and the value of the reflective process was questioned. Some students did recognize the value of undertaking and recording reflective self-assessment.
It appears that undergraduate students need a more gradual introduction to the process of reflective self-assessment. We suggest that the findings are linked to students' previous education experience and conclude there is a need for students to be encouraged to take ownership of their undergraduate learning, to gain confidence in self-assessment and to increase the value they place on reflection.
本研究旨在确定药学硕士一年级(MPharm)学生是否会参与类似于药剂师继续职业发展的活动,并探讨他们对这项任务的态度。
开发了一份纸质版的英国皇家药学会电子模板,用于记录继续职业发展情况。要求学生使用该纸质版模板记录完成书面作业时所进行的规划、行动和评估。对记录进行评估,以确定评估部分是否包含反思性自我评估,以及这种反思是否与指定的学习成果以及规划和行动阶段相关。开展了六个焦点小组讨论,期间学生们讨论了他们对完成这些记录的反应。该研究在英国中央兰开夏大学药学院和制药科学学院的药学硕士一年级本科学生第一学期期间进行。
发现很少有学生似乎完全参与了整个记录过程。在焦点小组讨论中,学生们提出了自我评估能力的问题,并对反思过程的价值提出了质疑。一些学生确实认识到进行和记录反思性自我评估的价值。
看来本科生需要更逐步地引入反思性自我评估过程。我们认为这些发现与学生以前的教育经历有关,并得出结论,需要鼓励学生对自己的本科学习负责,增强自我评估的信心,并提高他们对反思的重视程度。