Institute of Soil and Environmental Sciences, University of Agriculture, Faisalabad-38040, Pakistan.
Chemosphere. 2010 Apr;79(6):652-8. doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2010.01.066. Epub 2010 Mar 23.
A pot study was used to examine the effects of amendments such as EDTA and elemental sulfur on the growth potential, gas exchange features, uptake and mobilization of Pb by wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) in two texturally different contaminated soils at three levels of EDTA (2, 4, 8 mmol kg(-1) dry soil) and two levels of elemental sulfur (100, 200 mmol kg(-1) dry soil). EDTA resulted in more solubilization of Pb than elemental sulfur in both soils. Application of EDTA and elemental sulfur increased shoot dry matter in the loamy sand soil, whereas in the sandy clay loam soil EDTA treated plants produced lower shoot dry matter compared to that observed with elemental sulfur. Application of EDTA 10d prior to harvest increased the amount of Pb accumulated into wheat shoots with more Pb accumulated by plants from the loamy sand than from the sandy clay loam soil. However, evaluation of the relative extraction efficiency expressed as the percentage of solubilized Pb that is subsequently also effectively accumulated by the plant shoots reveals that the relatively low efficiency does not warrant the massive mobilization induced by the environmentally persistent EDTA chelator. More modest mobilization of Pb induced by elemental sulfur and the higher relative extraction of mobilized Pb therefore deserves further attention in future research. In particular, attention needs to be paid to determining soil types in which elemental sulfur can induce significant impact on soil pH and metal mobility after application of a practically realistic dosage.
采用盆栽试验研究了 EDTA 和元素硫等改良剂对两种质地不同的污染土壤中小麦(Triticum aestivum L.)生长潜力、气体交换特征、Pb 吸收和迁移的影响,EDTA 用量设 3 个水平(2、4、8 mmol kg(-1)干土),元素硫用量设 2 个水平(100、200 mmol kg(-1)干土)。与元素硫相比,EDTA 能使两种土壤中更多的 Pb 溶解。EDTA 和元素硫的施用增加了壤土砂土壤中的地上部干物质,而在砂壤土中,与元素硫相比,EDTA 处理的植物地上部干物质产量较低。收获前 10d 施用 EDTA 增加了 Pb 在小麦地上部的积累量,壤土砂中植物积累的 Pb 多于砂壤土。然而,评价相对提取效率(以溶解态 Pb 的百分比表示,随后也被植物地上部有效积累)表明,相对较低的效率并不保证环境持久性 EDTA 螯合剂诱导的大量 Pb 迁移。因此,元素硫诱导的 Pb 更适度的迁移和更高的可迁移 Pb 的相对提取率值得在未来的研究中进一步关注。特别是需要注意的是,确定在实际应用剂量下,元素硫能对土壤 pH 和金属迁移产生显著影响的土壤类型。