Azmoon Shah, Pucillo Anthony L, Aronow Wilbert S, Ebrahimi Ramin, Vozzolo Joseph, Rajdev Archana, Kalapatapu Kumar, Ro Jae H, Hjemdahl-Monsen Craig
Department Cardiology, New York Medical College, Macy Pavilion, Valhalla, NY 10595, USA.
J Invasive Cardiol. 2010 Apr;22(4):175-8.
We investigated the prevalence of vascular complications after PCI following hemostasis in 190 patients (67% men and 33% women, mean age 64 years) treated with the AngioSeal vascular closure device (St. Jude Medical, Austin, Texas) versus 238 patients (67% men and 33% women, mean age 64 years) treated with the Mynx vascular closure device (AccessClosure, Mountain View, California).
Death, myocardial infarction or stroke occurred in none of the 190 patients (0%) treated with the AngioSeal versus none of 238 patients (0%) treated with the Mynx. Major vascular complications occurred in 4 of 190 patients (2.1%) treated with the AngioSeal versus 5 of 238 patients (2.1%) treated with the Mynx (p not significant). Major vascular complications in patients treated with the AngioSeal included removal of a malfunctioning device (1.1%), hemorrhage requiring intervention (0.5%) and hemorrhage with a loss of > 3g Hgb (0.5%). The major vascular complications in patients treated with the Mynx included retroperitoneal bleeding requiring surgical intervention (0.8%), pseudoaneurysm with surgical repair (0.8%) and hemorrhage with a loss of > 3g Hgb (0.4%). These complications were not significantly different between the two vascular closure devices (p = 0.77). Minor complications included hematoma > 5 cm (0.5%, n = 1) within the AngioSeal group, as well as procedure failure requiring > 30 minutes of manual compression after device deployment, which occurred in 7 out of 190 patients (3.7%) treated with the AngioSeal versus 22 of 238 patients with the Mynx (9.2%) (p = 0.033).
Major vascular complications after PCI following hemostasis with vascular closure devices occurred in 2.1% of 190 patients treated with the AngioSeal vascular closure device versus 2.1% of 238 patients treated with the Mynx vascular closure device (p not significant). The Mynx vascular closure device appears to have a higher rate of device failure.
我们调查了190例(男性67%,女性33%,平均年龄64岁)接受AngioSeal血管闭合装置(圣犹达医疗公司,得克萨斯州奥斯汀)治疗与238例(男性67%,女性33%,平均年龄64岁)接受Mynx血管闭合装置(AccessClosure公司,加利福尼亚州山景城)治疗的患者在PCI止血后血管并发症的发生率。
接受AngioSeal治疗的190例患者中无死亡、心肌梗死或卒中发生(0%),接受Mynx治疗的238例患者中也无上述情况发生(0%)。接受AngioSeal治疗的190例患者中有4例(2.1%)发生主要血管并发症,接受Mynx治疗的238例患者中有5例(2.1%)发生主要血管并发症(P值无统计学意义)。接受AngioSeal治疗患者的主要血管并发症包括取出故障装置(1.1%)、需要干预的出血(0.5%)和血红蛋白丢失>3g的出血(0.5%)。接受Mynx治疗患者的主要血管并发症包括需要手术干预的腹膜后出血(0.8%)、手术修复的假性动脉瘤(0.8%)和血红蛋白丢失 >3g的出血(0.4%)。两种血管闭合装置的这些并发症无显著差异(P = 0.77)。轻微并发症包括AngioSeal组内血肿>5 cm(0.5%,n = 1),以及装置置入后需要>30分钟手动压迫的操作失败,接受AngioSeal治疗的190例患者中有7例(3.7%)发生,接受Mynx治疗的238例患者中有22例(9.2%)发生(P = 0.033)。
接受AngioSeal血管闭合装置治疗的190例患者中,PCI止血后主要血管并发症发生率为2.1%,接受Mynx血管闭合装置治疗的238例患者中为2.1%(P值无统计学意义)。Mynx血管闭合装置似乎有更高的装置失败率。