Metrick M E, Ritter F J, Gates J R, Jacobs M P, Skare S S, Loewenson R B
Department of Neurology, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis.
Epilepsia. 1991 May-Jun;32(3):322-8. doi: 10.1111/j.1528-1157.1991.tb04658.x.
The medical records of 27 children admitted to the MINCEP Epilepsy Program for evaluation of intractable epilepsy but later shown to have nonepileptic events by EEG with simultaneous video monitoring were reviewed. Four groups were identified: pure psychogenic events (5 patients), psychogenic events plus epileptic seizures (3 patients), pure nonepileptic physiologic events (5 patients), and nonepileptic physiologic events plus seizures (14 patients). Historical data, physical examinations, and neurodiagnostic evaluations (including previous EEGs, neuroradiologic evaluations, and neuropsychologic testing) were reviewed. Children in all groups, except for those with pure psychogenic seizures, had a history of multiple seizure types identified by parents or caretakers. A history of status epilepticus was obtained in 64% (of 22 patients), including 11 of 14 patients with physiologic events plus seizures. Abnormal findings on neurologic examination were common, especially in children with nonepileptic physiologic events. All but two patients had a history of interictal epileptiform abnormalities on previous routine EEGs. Based on identification of nonepileptic events, antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) were discontinued completely in eight patients (30%) and the total number of AEDs was reduced in nine others (33%). A diagnosis of nonepileptic events should be considered in all children with refractory seizures or multiple seizure types. Abnormal findings on routine (interictal) EEG may actually confound the diagnosis. Intensive neurodiagnostic EEG-video recording is the preferred method for distinguishing nonepileptic from epileptic seizures.
对27名因难治性癫痫而被纳入MINCEP癫痫项目进行评估,但后来通过脑电图同步视频监测显示为非癫痫性发作的儿童的病历进行了回顾。确定了四组:单纯性心因性发作(5例患者)、心因性发作加癫痫发作(3例患者)、单纯性非癫痫性生理发作(5例患者)以及非癫痫性生理发作加癫痫发作(14例患者)。回顾了病史资料、体格检查以及神经诊断评估(包括既往脑电图、神经放射学评估和神经心理学测试)。除了单纯性心因性发作的儿童外,所有组的儿童都有家长或照料者确定的多种发作类型的病史。64%(22例患者中的)患者有癫痫持续状态病史,包括14例生理发作加癫痫发作患者中的11例。神经系统检查异常发现很常见,尤其是在有非癫痫性生理发作的儿童中。除两名患者外,所有患者既往常规脑电图检查均有发作间期癫痫样异常病史。基于非癫痫性发作的诊断,8例患者(30%)完全停用了抗癫痫药物(AEDs),另外9例患者(33%)的AEDs总数减少。对于所有难治性发作或多种发作类型的儿童,都应考虑非癫痫性发作的诊断。常规(发作间期)脑电图的异常发现实际上可能会混淆诊断。强化神经诊断性脑电图-视频记录是区分非癫痫性发作和癫痫性发作的首选方法。