Ingebrigtsen Tor
Administrasjonen, Universitetssykehuset Nord-Norge, Postboks 100 9038 Tromsø, Norway.
Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen. 2010 May 6;130(9):940-2. doi: 10.4045/tidsskr.09.0998.
Norwegian hospitals have been characterised by increasing activity, expansion of services and increasing costs for a long time. Differences in quality and accessibility have been documented between hospitals in various geographic locations. Transferral of hospital ownership to the state (from 2002) aimed at increasing capacities and improving quality of services, but also at restricting the increase of costs. These goals have only been partly met. The structure of hospital trusts and organisation of services are therefore continuously debated. This literature review aims at examining whether hospital mergers can reduce costs and at the same time increase the quality of services offered.
Literature was identified through a Medline search using the terms "hospital", "merger" and "cost saving". The results are summarized and discussed.
Seven original studies of totally 476 hospital mergers (in the USA, Great Britain and Norway) were identified in the period 1982 - 2000.
The literature indicates that hospital mergers have a potential to reduce costs by about 10 % if the process achieves complete fusion of previously independent organisations, with a more optimal dimensioning of services and development of a common organizational culture. Collaboration between top management and the professional bureaucracy are prerequisites for success. Mergers are associated with a significant risk of unexpected problems and temporary reduced quality of the services.
长期以来,挪威医院的特点是业务活动增加、服务范围扩大以及成本上升。不同地理位置的医院在质量和可及性方面存在差异已有记录。医院所有权向国家转移(始于2002年)旨在提高服务能力和改善服务质量,同时限制成本增长。但这些目标仅部分实现。因此,医院信托结构和服务组织一直备受争议。本综述旨在研究医院合并是否能降低成本并同时提高所提供服务的质量。
通过使用“医院”“合并”和“成本节约”等术语在Medline数据库中进行检索来确定文献。对结果进行总结和讨论。
在1982年至2000年期间,共确定了7项关于476起医院合并(在美国、英国和挪威)的原始研究。
文献表明,如果合并过程能实现对先前独立组织的完全融合,对服务进行更优化的规模调整并发展共同的组织文化,医院合并有可能将成本降低约10%。高层管理人员与专业官僚机构之间的合作是成功的先决条件。合并伴随着出现意外问题和服务质量暂时下降的重大风险。