Repko M, Chaloupka R
Ortopedická klinika FN Brno-Bohunice.
Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2000;67(6):387-93.
PURPOSE OF THE STUDY The study evaluated the possibilities of the application of the surgical method of fusion and the mutual comparison of its individual types in the treatment of planovalgus deformity in the foot in spastic patients affected by infantile cerebral palsy. Escalated spasm of eversion muscles of the foot with a simultaneous weakening of tibial muscles resulted in their case in relatively very severe deformities of feet and their poor function. The decision on the type of the chosen arthrodesis (extraarticular talocalcanear or triple subtalar) is based on the bone maturity of the patient and the degree of the possible correction of the deformity. On their own group of patients the authors present their experience in the application of the two types of arthrodesis and point out the necessity of an early treatment of the deformity by a less extensive and more considerate type of extraarticular arthrodesis, in their case with the use of a tricortical pelvic bone graft after Grice-Thomas. MATERIAL At the Orthopaedic Department of the Faculty Hospital Brno-Bohunice we treated in the period of 1992-1999 by arthrodesis 31 patients (49 feet) with the basic diagnosis of the spastic form of infantile cerebral palsy.The group comprises 27 girls and 22 boys. Forty-one feet (84 %) was operated on by the method of extrarticular talocalcanear arthrodesis after Grice with the use of a tricortical pelvic bone graft modification afterThomas.The average age of the patients in this group was at the time of operation 10 years and 8 months. The method of a triple subtalar fusion was used for the operation of 8 feet (16 %) in patients of the average age of 19 years and 9 months at the time of the operation. The combined method with the simultaneous lengthening of the shortened Achilles tendon was used in 21 feet. In 18 feet the lengthening of the Achilles tendon as a separate operation was performed prior to the arthrodesis. Ten Achilles tendons did not require such lengthening. A simultaneous combination of the transposition of the tibialis angerior muscle tendon (the Young technique) with extraarticular arthrodesis was used in 19 feet. Surgical results were evaluated on the basis of x-ray measurable angles, the talocalcanear angle in particular, measured on the lateral radiograph. Of great importance is the monitoring of the change of the movement stereotype and clinical examination with the possibility of photo and video documentation. RESULTS The average follow-up of our group of patients is 4 years and 5 months after operation. The minimum follow-up is 12 months after the operation. Regular clinical and x-ray examinations inform about clinical condition of the deformity (derotation of the heel, condition of the longitudinal arch), walking stereotype and evaluation of the position of the bone graft. The results may be divided into 3 categories. The category of excellent results comprises 25 (61 %) operated on feet from the group of extraarticular arthrodesis and 3 feet (37 %) from the group of triple arthrodesis. The category of satisfactory results included 13 (32 %) operated on feet from the first group and 4 feet (50 %) from the second group and 3 operated on feet (7 %) from the first group and 1 foot (13 %) from the second group fell into the category of unsatisfactory results. The talocalcanear angle had a mean preoperative value of 43,5 degrees (28-54) and its postoperative average value was 27 degrees (20-37). The average correction is 16,5 degrees . DISCUSSION In the discussion the authors compared the Thomas technique of harvesting tricortical bone grafts from the iliac crest with harvesting bone grafts from other locations (tibia, fibula, rib, etc.) The main reasons why the authors prefer this type of bone graft is mainly the solidity of the pelvic bone graft, the possibility to avoid its internal fixation, a quality ingrowth of the bone graft and excellent healing of the harvesting location. They compare their experience with the works of Banwart, Bar ras, Dennyson, Lancaster, McCall. Partio, Pirani and Smetana. CONCLUSIONS Both types of fusion have significantly contributed to the solution of planovalgus deformity of the foot in spastic patients. An early extraarticular arthrodesis brings high quality results of the functional condition of the foot. This method can prevent the necessary treatment of a rigid painful planovalgus deformity of the foot in the adult age requiring an extensive operation with the resection of subtalar joints. Both types of arthrodesis increase the stability of planovalgus feet and improve the walking stereotype in general.
planovalgosity of the foot, cerebral palsy, arthrodesis.
研究目的 本研究评估了融合手术方法在治疗小儿脑性瘫痪痉挛型患者足扁平外翻畸形中的应用可能性及其不同类型之间的相互比较。足部外翻肌痉挛加剧,同时胫骨肌减弱,导致这些患者出现相对严重的足部畸形及其功能障碍。所选关节固定术(关节外距下或三关节距下)类型的决定基于患者的骨骼成熟度和畸形可能矫正的程度。作者介绍了他们在一组患者中应用两种类型关节固定术的经验,并指出通过不太广泛且更周全的关节外关节固定术早期治疗畸形的必要性,在他们的病例中采用了Grice - Thomas术后的三皮质骨盆骨移植。材料 在布尔诺 - 博胡尼采大学医院骨科,我们在1992 - 1999年期间对31例(49足)基本诊断为痉挛型小儿脑性瘫痪的患者进行了关节固定术治疗。该组包括27名女孩和22名男孩。41足(84%)采用Grice法关节外距下关节固定术并使用Thomas改良的三皮质骨盆骨移植进行手术。该组患者手术时的平均年龄为10岁8个月。8足(16%)采用三关节距下融合术,手术时患者的平均年龄为19岁9个月。21足采用了同时延长缩短跟腱的联合方法。18足在关节固定术前单独进行了跟腱延长手术。10条跟腱不需要这种延长。19足采用了胫前肌腱转位(Young技术)与关节外关节固定术的同时联合。手术结果根据X线可测量角度进行评估,特别是在侧位X线片上测量的距下关节角度。运动模式的变化监测以及临床检查并进行照片和视频记录非常重要。结果 我们这组患者术后的平均随访时间为4年5个月。最短随访时间为术后12个月。定期临床和X线检查可了解畸形的临床状况(足跟旋转、纵弓状况)、行走模式以及骨移植位置的评估。结果可分为3类。优秀结果类别包括关节外关节固定术组的手术足中的25足(61%)和三关节固定术组的3足(37%)。满意结果类别包括第一组手术足中的13足(32%)和第二组的4足(50%),第一组手术足中的3足(7%)和第二组的1足(13%)属于不满意结果类别。距下关节角度术前平均值为43.5度(28 - 54度),术后平均值为27度(20 - 37度)。平均矫正度为16.5度。讨论 在讨论中,作者将从髂嵴获取三皮质骨移植的Thomas技术与从其他部位(胫骨、腓骨、肋骨等)获取骨移植进行了比较。作者更喜欢这种类型骨移植的主要原因主要是骨盆骨移植的坚固性、避免其内部固定的可能性、骨移植的良好长入以及取骨部位的良好愈合。他们将自己的经验与Banwart、Bar ras、Dennyson、Lancaster、McCall、Partio、Pirani和Smetana的研究进行了比较。结论 两种类型的融合术都对解决痉挛型患者足部扁平外翻畸形有显著贡献。早期关节外关节固定术能带来足部功能状况的高质量结果。这种方法可以避免成年后因严重疼痛的僵硬扁平外翻畸形而需要进行广泛的距下关节切除手术的必要治疗。两种类型的关节固定术都增加了扁平外翻足的稳定性并总体改善了行走模式。
足部扁平外翻、脑瘫、关节固定术