University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104-6179, USA.
J Womens Health (Larchmt). 2010 Jun;19(6):1079-87. doi: 10.1089/jwh.2009.1612.
Few studies have examined adolescent victims of intimate partner violence (IPV) whose victimization is reported to the police or the nature of the incidents that led to the police call. This oversight is problematic for healthcare providers, given that overlap between the use of healthcare and police services is high among IPV victims. We assessed the frequency and nature of police-documented incidents of IPV by men against female adolescents aged 15-17 compared with those against young women aged 18-22.
A systematic case ascertainment strategy was applied to administrative data from the Compstat database of a large U.S. metropolitan police department to identify IPV incidents with victims <23 years old. We created additional variables from incident narratives and conducted descriptive analyses on the identified cases.
During January-September 2005, police filed reports on 1607 incidents of IPV against women <23 years old: one tenth were younger than 18. Although their risk of police-documented IPV was lower, adolescents' experiences of IPV were remarkably similar to those of 18-22-year-olds. As with adult victims, most assaults against adolescents were through bodily force (94.4%) and occurred in a private residence (75.0%). A substantial minority of adolescents were in adultlike relationships: 9.0% were married, 31.3% were cohabiting, and 20.2% had a child in common. A higher proportion of adolescents, however, experienced an aggravated (vs. simple) assault (11.1%) and sustained visible injuries (12.1%).
The commonalities between adolescent and young women's experiences of IPV regarding the nature of the assault, observed injuries, and relationship to assailants have important implications for policy and practice. Findings suggest that routine screening for IPV should begin in adolescence to help prevent future abuse and injury.
鲜有研究调查过向警方报告亲密伴侣暴力(IPV)的青少年受害者,以及导致报警的事件性质。对于医疗保健提供者来说,这种疏忽是有问题的,因为在 IPV 受害者中,使用医疗保健和警察服务之间存在高度重叠。我们评估了与 18-22 岁年轻女性相比,15-17 岁男性针对女性青少年的 IPV 事件中警方记录的事件频率和性质。
应用美国一个大都市区警察局 Compstat 数据库的系统病例发现策略,从行政数据中确定了 23 岁以下受害者的 IPV 事件。我们从事件叙述中创建了其他变量,并对确定的病例进行了描述性分析。
在 2005 年 1 月至 9 月期间,警方对 1607 起针对 23 岁以下女性的 IPV 事件提出了报告:十分之一的受害者年龄小于 18 岁。尽管她们有记录的 IPV 风险较低,但青少年的 IPV 经历与 18-22 岁的女性非常相似。与成年受害者一样,大多数针对青少年的攻击都是通过身体暴力(94.4%)和在私人住所(75.0%)发生的。相当一部分青少年处于成人关系中:9.0%已婚,31.3%同居,20.2%有共同的孩子。然而,青少年中更有比例的人经历了加重(而非简单)的攻击(11.1%)和明显的受伤(12.1%)。
青少年和年轻女性在袭击性质、观察到的伤害和与攻击者的关系方面的 IPV 经历存在共性,这对政策和实践具有重要意义。研究结果表明,应在青少年时期开始常规筛查 IPV,以帮助预防未来的虐待和伤害。