Vasudevan Arumugam, Venkat Ranjani, Badhe Ashok Shankar
Departments of Anesthesiology and Critical Care, Jawaharlal Institute of Postgraduate Medical Education and Research (JIPMER), Puducherry, India.
Indian J Anaesth. 2010 Jan;54(1):45-8. doi: 10.4103/0019-5049.60497.
Successful endotracheal intubation requires a clear view of glottis. Optimal external laryngeal manipulation may improve the view of glottis on direct laryngoscopy with Macintosh blade, but it requires another trained hand. Alternatively, McCoy laryngoscope with elevated tip may be useful. This study has been designed to compare the two techniques in patients with poor view of glottis. Two hundred patients with 'Grade 2 or more' view of glottis on direct laryngoscopy with Macintosh blade are included in the study. Optimal external laryngeal manipulation was applied, followed by laryngoscopy with McCoy blade in activated position; and the view was noted in both situations. The two interventions were compared using Chi-square test. The overall changes, in the views, were analyzed with Wilcoxon signed rank test. Both the techniques improved the view of glottis significantly (P<0.05). Optimal external laryngeal manipulation was significantly better than McCoy laryngoscope in active position, especially in patients with Grade 3 or 4 baseline view, poor oropharyngeal class, decreased head extension and decreased submandibular space (odds ratio = 2.36, 3.17, 3.22 and 26.48 respectively). To conclude, optimal external laryngeal manipulation is a better technique than McCoy laryngoscope in patients with poor view of glottis on direct laryngoscopy with Macintosh blade.
成功的气管插管需要清晰看到声门。最佳的外部喉部操作可能会改善使用麦金托什喉镜直接喉镜检查时声门的视野,但这需要另一只受过训练的手。另外,尖端可抬起的麦科伊喉镜可能会有用。本研究旨在比较在声门视野不佳的患者中这两种技术。该研究纳入了200例使用麦金托什喉镜直接喉镜检查时声门视野为“2级或更高”的患者。应用最佳的外部喉部操作,然后使用处于激活位置的麦科伊喉镜进行喉镜检查;并记录两种情况下的视野。使用卡方检验比较这两种干预措施。用威尔科克森符号秩检验分析视野的总体变化。两种技术均显著改善了声门视野(P<0.05)。最佳的外部喉部操作在激活位置明显优于麦科伊喉镜,尤其是在基线视野为3级或4级、口咽分级差、头部伸展减少和下颌下间隙减小的患者中(优势比分别为2.36、3.17、3.22和26.48)。总之,在使用麦金托什喉镜直接喉镜检查时声门视野不佳的患者中,最佳的外部喉部操作是比麦科伊喉镜更好的技术。