Agarwal A, Agarwal R
CNBC, Geeta Colony, Delhi, India.
Educ Health (Abingdon). 2010 Apr;23(1):225. Epub 2010 Apr 21.
Traditional bonesetting is an art that in the face of urbanization, lack of public attention and lack of modern facilities has survived more than 3,000 years. This article explores the role of bonesetters in the developing world, their successes and failures and possible utilization of their services as part of the healthcare system of a country.
Articles depicting working or techniques of bonesetters or those related to training and education issues of traditional bonesetters, especially in developing countries, were reviewed. The current scenario of healthcare delivery and medical education along with existing socioeconomic conditions prevailing in India were analyzed with generalization of findings to the healthcare delivery systems of other developing countries.
Bonesetting has its strengths and weaknesses. With current socioeconomic conditions and the types of health needs prevailing in developing countries, it would be difficult to abolish traditional bonesetting. These providers have widespread community acceptance and support. Complications can be minimized and practice potentially improved with training and education.
Pending infrastructure and socioeconomic development, it appears that traditional bonesetters will remain providers of healthcare. Their methodology utilizes regional resources and is commonly believed to be cheaper and effective. Although the deficiencies of traditional bonesetters have been shown, with adequate training in the basics of orthopaedic care, they can be utilized to provide useful health services at the primary care level.
传统正骨术是一门艺术,面对城市化、缺乏公众关注以及缺乏现代设施的情况,它已存续了三千多年。本文探讨了正骨师在发展中国家所起的作用、他们的成败以及其服务作为一国医疗体系一部分的可能利用方式。
对描述正骨师工作或技术的文章,或与传统正骨师培训和教育问题相关的文章进行了综述,尤其是在发展中国家的情况。分析了印度当前的医疗服务提供和医学教育现状以及现有的社会经济状况,并将研究结果推广至其他发展中国家的医疗服务体系。
正骨术有其优势和劣势。鉴于发展中国家当前的社会经济状况和普遍存在的健康需求类型,废除传统正骨术将很困难。这些从业者得到了广泛的社区认可和支持。通过培训和教育,并发症可降至最低,业务水平也可能得到提升。
在基础设施和社会经济发展到位之前,传统正骨师似乎仍将是医疗服务的提供者。他们的方法利用了当地资源,通常被认为成本更低且效果良好。尽管传统正骨师存在不足之处,但通过接受充足的骨科护理基础知识培训,他们可被利用来在初级保健层面提供有益的健康服务。