Meerpohl Joerg J, Antes Gerd, Rücker Gerta, Fleeman Nigel, Niemeyer Charlotte, Bassler Dirk
German Cochrane Centre, Institute of Medical Biometry & Medical Informatics and Pediatric Hematology & Oncology, Center for Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, University Medical Center Freiburg, Berliner Allee 29, Freiburg, Germany, 79110.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2010 Aug 4(8):CD007477. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007477.pub2.
Sickle cell disease (SCD) is a group of genetic haemoglobin disorders. Increasingly, some people with SCD develop secondary iron overload due to occasional red blood cell transfusions or are on long-term transfusion programmes for e.g. secondary stroke prevention. Iron chelation therapy can prevent long-term complications.Deferoxamine and deferiprone have been found to be efficacious. However, questions exist about the effectiveness and safety of the new oral chelator deferasirox.
To assess the effectiveness and safety of oral deferasirox in people with SCD and secondary iron overload.
We searched the Cystic Fibrosis & Genetic Disorders Group's Haemoglobinopathies Trials Register (06 April 2010).We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, EBMR, Biosis Previews, Web of Science, Derwent Drug File, XTOXLINE and three trial registries: www.controlled-trials.com; www.clinicaltrials.gov; www.who.int./ictrp/en/. Most recent searches: 22 June 2009.
Randomised controlled trials comparing deferasirox with no therapy or placebo or with another iron chelating treatment schedule.
Two authors independently assessed study quality and extracted data. We contacted the study author for additional information.
One study (203 people) was included comparing the efficacy and safety of deferasirox and deferoxamine after 12 months. Data were not available on mortality or end-organ damage. Using a pre-specified dosing algorithm serum ferritin reduction was similar in both groups, mean difference (MD) 375.00 microg/l in favour of deferoxamine; (95% confidence interval (CI) -106.08 to 856.08). Liver iron concentration measured by superconduction quantum interference device showed no difference for the overall group of patients adjusted for transfusion category, MD -0.20 mg Fe/g dry weight (95% CI -3.15 to 2.75).Mild stable increases in creatine were observed more often in people treated with deferasirox, risk ratio 1.64 (95% CI 0.98 to 2.74). Abdominal pain and diarrhoea occurred significantly more often in people treated with deferasirox. Rare adverse events (less than 5% increase) were not reported; long-term adverse events could not be measured in the included study (follow-up 52 weeks). Patient satisfaction with, and convenience of treatment were significantly better with deferasirox.
AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: Deferasirox appears to be as effective as deferoxamine. However, only limited evidence is available assessing the efficacy regarding patient-important outcomes. The short-term safety of deferasirox seems to be acceptable, however, follow-up was too short to exclude long-term side effects and thus treatment with deferasirox cannot be judged completely safe. Future studies should assess long-term outcomes for safety and efficacy, and also evaluate rarer adverse effects.
镰状细胞病(SCD)是一组遗传性血红蛋白疾病。越来越多的SCD患者因偶尔的红细胞输血而出现继发性铁过载,或因例如二级中风预防等原因接受长期输血治疗。铁螯合疗法可以预防长期并发症。已发现去铁胺和去铁酮有效。然而,新型口服螯合剂地拉罗司的有效性和安全性存在疑问。
评估口服地拉罗司对SCD和继发性铁过载患者的有效性和安全性。
我们检索了囊性纤维化与遗传疾病组的血红蛋白病试验注册库(2010年4月6日)。我们检索了MEDLINE、EMBASE、EBMR、生物摘要数据库、科学引文索引、德温特药物文件、XTOXLINE以及三个试验注册库:www.controlled-trials.com;www.clinicaltrials.gov;www.who.int./ictrp/en/。最近一次检索时间为2009年6月22日。
比较地拉罗司与未治疗、安慰剂或其他铁螯合治疗方案的随机对照试验。
两位作者独立评估研究质量并提取数据。我们联系研究作者获取更多信息。
纳入一项研究(203人),比较12个月后地拉罗司和去铁胺的疗效和安全性。未获得关于死亡率或终末器官损害的数据。使用预先指定的给药算法,两组血清铁蛋白降低情况相似,有利于去铁胺的平均差值(MD)为375.00μg/L;(95%置信区间(CI)-106.08至856.08)。通过超导量子干涉装置测量的肝脏铁浓度在根据输血类别调整的总体患者组中无差异,MD为-0.20mg铁/克干重(95%CI-3.15至2.75)。接受地拉罗司治疗的患者更常出现轻度稳定的肌酸升高,风险比为1.64(95%CI0.98至2.74)。接受地拉罗司治疗的患者腹痛和腹泻发生率明显更高。未报告罕见不良事件(增加少于5%);纳入的研究中无法测量长期不良事件(随访52周)。患者对地拉罗司的满意度和治疗便利性明显更好。
地拉罗司似乎与去铁胺一样有效。然而,评估对患者重要结局的疗效的证据有限。地拉罗司的短期安全性似乎可以接受,然而,随访时间过短,无法排除长期副作用,因此不能完全判定地拉罗司治疗是安全的。未来的研究应评估长期的安全性和疗效结局,还应评估更罕见的不良反应。