Department of Anesthesiology, Hadassah Hebrew University Medical Center, Jerusalem, Israel.
Int J Obstet Anesth. 2010 Oct;19(4):410-6. doi: 10.1016/j.ijoa.2010.04.009. Epub 2010 Aug 13.
This survey was performed to assess the organization and practice of obstetric anesthesia units in Israel.
A written questionnaire was mailed at the end of December 2005 to all Israeli anesthesia departments providing labor and delivery services in 2005 (n=25).
A response rate of 100% accounted for 125,340 deliveries. All labor and delivery suites had on-site anesthesia department services. Data are presented as mean (range) or frequency. Eleven hospitals performed 2500-4999 deliveries/year, 6 hospitals 5000-7499 deliveries/year, and 4 hospitals 7500-9999 deliveries/year. The overall cesarean delivery rate was 20% (0-27). Anesthesia for cesarean delivery (elective and emergency combined) was provided by: general anesthesia 15% (0.5-50), epidural 14.5% (0-99.5), spinal 68% (0-98), or combined spinal-epidural technique 0% (0-30). There was an operating room within or immediately adjacent to the labor ward in 16/25 units, including 10/11 units with >5000 deliveries/year. Labor analgesia was provided by epidural techniques in 50% (4-93) and nitrous oxide in 0.5% (0-90) of deliveries. A total of 11 units had 24h dedicated anesthesiologist coverage, including all units >7500 deliveries but only 3/8 (38%) with 5000-7500 deliveries. Two of the 4 units with >7500 deliveries had no faculty member with formal training in obstetric anesthesia. Written protocols were available for labor analgesia (17/25), post-partum hemorrhage (12/25), aspiration prophylaxis (15/25) and maternal resuscitation (8/25).
In this national appraisal of Israeli obstetric anesthesia services, a notable lack of written protocols, wide variations in staffing, and few specifically trained obstetric anesthesia personnel were observed.
本调查旨在评估以色列产科麻醉单位的组织和实践情况。
2005 年 12 月底,向 2005 年提供分娩服务的所有以色列麻醉部门(n=25)邮寄了一份书面问卷。
100%的回复率代表了 125340 次分娩。所有分娩套房都有现场麻醉部门服务。数据以平均值(范围)或频率表示。11 家医院每年进行 2500-4999 次分娩,6 家医院每年进行 5000-7499 次分娩,4 家医院每年进行 7500-9999 次分娩。总体剖宫产率为 20%(0-27)。剖宫产(择期和紧急)的麻醉方式为:全身麻醉 15%(0.5-50),硬膜外麻醉 14.5%(0-99.5),脊髓麻醉 68%(0-98),或联合脊髓-硬膜外技术 0%(0-30)。在 25 个单位中有 16 个/单位的手术室位于产房内或紧邻产房,其中 10 个/单位每年进行 5000 次以上分娩。50%(4-93)的分娩采用硬膜外技术提供分娩镇痛,0.5%(0-90)的分娩采用笑气。共有 11 个单位有 24 小时专职麻醉师覆盖,包括所有每年进行 7500 次以上分娩的单位,但只有 3/8(38%)每年进行 5000-7500 次分娩的单位。在每年进行 7500 次以上分娩的 4 个单位中,有 2 个单位没有接受过产科麻醉正规培训的教员。有书面方案的项目包括分娩镇痛(17/25)、产后出血(12/25)、误吸预防(15/25)和产妇复苏(8/25)。
在这项对以色列产科麻醉服务的全国评估中,观察到书面方案缺乏、人员配置差异大以及很少有专门接受过产科麻醉培训的人员。