Müller M, Meyer H, Stummer H
Department für Human- und Wirtschaftswissenschaften, Private Universität für Gesundheitswissenschaften, medizinische Informatikund Technik, Opernring 5 / 2, Vienna, Austria.
Gesundheitswesen. 2011 Jul;73(7):443-9. doi: 10.1055/s-0030-1255081. Epub 2010 Sep 23.
In extramural setting, general practitioners serve as gatekeepers and therefore control the demand for medical treatment and pharmaceuticals. As a result prescription habits are of major interest.
The aim of the present study is to identify sample characteristics in the prescription behaviour of the general practitioners that allow one to differentiate between the individual and the basic population.
The prescription behaviour of 4 231 general practitioners was operationalised by means of the two variables "quantity" and "price". Outliers in those categories, that indicate a doctor prescribing too many or too expensive drugs, were identified using Chebyshev's inequality.
We found a statistically significant linear relationship between the individual characteristics of the medical doctors and their prescription behaviour (0.54≤ r ≤0.89) as well as between the variables "quantity" and "price" (r=0.86). Particularly notable seems to be the correlation between the number of the consultations and the quantity of the prescribed drugs. The average prescription amounts to approximately 1.8 pharmaceuticals per consultation. The quantity of drugs prescribed correlates with the demand for the physician's service. Only a few general practitioners deviate from this coherence. The tendency to prescribe disproportionately expensive drugs (average costs amount to € 18.4 per drug) especially applies to those general practitioners who, in addition to their occupation as a physician, are allowed to dispense the pharmaceuticals directly to the patient within their privately owned pharmacies ("Hausapotheke"). In addition to this attribute, the variables "number of patients" and "number of consultations" intensify the effect. The risk to be identified as an outlier is 7 times higher within the group of general practitioners who own a "Hausapotheke" and account for an above average number of consultations as within the group that does not incorporate those characteristics.
The strong coherence between the quantity and the demand is inherent to the health-care system and explains 79% of the variance of the prescribed quantities. Only 21% of the variance is determined by outside influences such as state of health of the patients. Physicians who have a monetary benefit from also distributing the drugs, however, enhance the prescription of high priced pharmaceuticals.
在非机构环境中,全科医生充当守门人,因此控制着医疗和药品需求。因此,处方习惯备受关注。
本研究的目的是确定全科医生处方行为中的样本特征,以便区分个体与总体人群。
通过“数量”和“价格”这两个变量来衡量4231名全科医生的处方行为。使用切比雪夫不等式识别这些类别中的异常值,即开药过多或过贵的医生。
我们发现医生的个人特征与其处方行为之间存在统计学上显著的线性关系(0.54≤r≤0.89),以及“数量”和“价格”变量之间存在线性关系(r = 0.86)。特别值得注意的似乎是会诊次数与所开药品数量之间的相关性。每次会诊的平均处方量约为1.8种药品。所开药品数量与对医生服务的需求相关。只有少数全科医生偏离这种一致性。开具价格过高药品的倾向(平均每种药品成本为18.4欧元)尤其适用于那些除了作为医生职业外,还被允许在其私人药店(“家庭药房”)直接向患者配药的全科医生。除了这一属性外,“患者数量”和“会诊次数”变量会增强这种影响。在拥有“家庭药房”且会诊次数高于平均水平的全科医生群体中被识别为异常值的风险,是不具备这些特征的群体的7倍。
数量与需求之间的强一致性是医疗保健系统所固有的,解释了处方量79%的方差。只有21%的方差由患者健康状况等外部因素决定。然而,从药品分发中获得经济利益的医生会增加高价药品的处方量。