Department of Physical Therapy, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada.
Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2010 Nov;91(11):1752-7. doi: 10.1016/j.apmr.2010.07.226.
To evaluate the interrater, intrarater, and test-retest reliability of the total performance and safety scores of the Wheelchair Skills Test version 4.1 (WST 4.1) for manual wheelchairs operated by adult wheelchair users.
Cohort study.
University research setting.
People (N=11) who used manual wheelchairs for community locomotion.
Not applicable.
Participants were videotaped as they completed the WST 4.1 (30 skills) on 2 separate occasions 1 to 2 weeks apart. Subsequently, raters scored the WST 4.1 from the video recordings and each participant received a total score for performance and safety. Using those scores, interrater, intrarater, and test-retest reliability were determined by using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs). Percentages of agreement between raters for individual skills also were calculated.
Mean ± SD overall WST 4.1 scores for performance and safety were 80.1%±8.5% and 98.0%±2.8%. ICCs for the interrater, intrarater, and test-retest reliability of the performance component were .855, .950, and .901 (P<.001). Safety component ICC scores were .061 (P=.243), .228 (P=.048), and .254 (P=.041). Percentages of agreement between raters for each test item for both the performance and safety scales ranged from 68% to 100%.
Reliability of the performance component of the WST 4.1 was excellent, whereas ICCs for the safety component indicated only slight to fair agreement, probably because of the low variability in safety scores. Additional study is needed to further evaluate the reliability of the safety component with a larger and more diverse sample group.
评估成人手动轮椅使用者操作的轮椅技能测试第 4.1 版(WST 4.1)的总体表现和安全性评分的评分者间、评分者内和重测信度。
队列研究。
大学研究环境。
使用手动轮椅进行社区活动的人(N=11)。
不适用。
参与者在相隔 1 至 2 周的 2 个不同时间点通过录像完成 WST 4.1(30 项技能)。随后,评分者根据录像对 WST 4.1 进行评分,每位参与者获得表现和安全性的总分。使用这些分数,通过组内相关系数(ICC)确定评分者间、评分者内和重测信度。还计算了评分者对个别技能的一致性百分比。
表现和安全性的 WST 4.1 总分平均值±标准差分别为 80.1%±8.5%和 98.0%±2.8%。表现部分的评分者间、评分者内和重测信度的 ICC 分别为.855、.950 和.901(P<.001)。安全部分的 ICC 评分分别为.061(P=.243)、.228(P=.048)和.254(P=.041)。表现和安全性量表的每个测试项目的评分者间一致性百分比范围为 68%至 100%。
WST 4.1 的表现部分的可靠性为优秀,而安全部分的 ICC 表明仅存在轻微至中等的一致性,可能是由于安全评分的变异性较低。需要进一步研究以使用更大、更多样化的样本组进一步评估安全部分的可靠性。