Nurminen Lauri, Peromaa Tarja, Laurinen Pentti
Brain Research Unit, Low Temperature Laboratory, Aalto University School of Science and Technology, Espoo, Finland.
J Vis. 2010 Nov 11;10(13):9. doi: 10.1167/10.13.9.
Surround modulation of perceived contrast has been almost exclusively studied in short-range conditions, i.e., in situations where a tiny gap, at most, separates center from surround. Existing long-range studies suggest that suppression extends to 12-cycle distance, whereas facilitation of perceived contrast is suggested to arise from visual field regions enclosing the center. In V1 neurons, however, long-range surround modulation involves both suppression and facilitation. Thus, we investigated short- and long-range surround modulation by measuring the perceived contrast of a center in the presence of a surround either near (0.3 cycles, 0.1 degree) or far (19.8 cycles, 6.6 degrees) from the center. This study demonstrates that in addition to the well-known suppression, surround modulation involves remarkably long-range facilitation of perceived contrast. At low center contrasts, the long-range facilitation was stronger than the long-range suppression, whereas at high center contrast we found mainly long-range suppression. Because the current models of perceived contrast could not account for our data, we considered our results in the context of models developed for surround modulation in V1 neurons. However, neither mechanistic nor phenomenological models proved satisfactory. Moreover, with the current knowledge, it seems that straightforward pooling of V1 neurons' responses cannot account for surround modulation of perceived contrast.
对感知对比度的周边调制几乎完全是在短程条件下进行研究的,即中心与周边之间最多只存在微小间隙的情况。现有的长程研究表明,抑制作用可延伸至12个周期的距离,而感知对比度的增强则被认为源于包围中心的视野区域。然而,在初级视觉皮层(V1)神经元中,长程周边调制同时涉及抑制和增强。因此,我们通过测量在周边存在的情况下中心的感知对比度,研究了短程和长程周边调制,周边与中心的距离分别为近(0.3个周期,0.1度)或远(19.8个周期,6.6度)。这项研究表明,除了众所周知的抑制作用外,周边调制还涉及感知对比度显著的长程增强。在低中心对比度下,长程增强比长程抑制更强,而在高中心对比度下,我们主要发现长程抑制。由于当前的感知对比度模型无法解释我们的数据,我们在为V1神经元周边调制开发的模型背景下考虑了我们的结果。然而,无论是机制模型还是现象学模型都不能令人满意。此外,就目前的知识而言,似乎直接汇总V1神经元的反应无法解释感知对比度的周边调制。