Yun Zhong-Jie, Chen Pei-Zhong, Bian Jian-Chao, Wang Yu-Tao, Gao Jie, Ma Ai-Hua, Liu Yuan, Li Heng-Xiang
Shandong Institute of Prevention and Control for Endemic Disease, Jinan 250014, China. Email:
Zhonghua Liu Xing Bing Xue Za Zhi. 2010 Nov;31(11):1280-3.
To investigate the current prevalent status of endemic fluorosis in the floodplain area of the lower Yellow River in Shandong province.
According to "The National Technical Scheme for Endemic Disease Control in 2008", 16 counties were chosen to carry out the epidemiological survey of endemic fluorosis. Three villages were chosen in each county, to determine the fluoride content of drinking water and to check the dental fluorosis of children aged 8 to 12 year old, the skeletal fluorosis of adults over 16 years of age. Both children and adults were tested for urine fluoride. The content of fluoride in drinking water and urine was determined by F-ion selective electrode while dental fluorosis of children aged 8 to 12 years old was diagnosed by Dean's method and adults skeletal fluorosis by the National Standard for "Diagnosis of endemic skeletal fluorosis" (WS 192-2008).
The investigation was taken place in 26 'improved-water-quality' villages in 16 counties, among which 19 villages had water fluoride content ≤ 1.00 mg/L and accounted for 73.08% (19/26), 7 villages had water fluoride content > 1.00 mg/L and accounted for 26.92% (7/26), with the highest water fluoride content as 3.73 mg/L. In 22 'yet to improve-water quality' villages in 16 counties, 5 villages had water fluoride content ≤ 1.00 mg/L (accounted for 22.73%), 17 villages had water fluoride content > 1.00 mg/L (accounted for 77.27%), with the highest water fluoride content as 3.38 mg/L. The overall rate of dental fluorosis among children aged 8 to 12 years old was 52.18% (1042/1997), with the index of dental fluorosis as 1.17 and the rate of dental damage as 8.01% (160/1997). The urinary fluoride values above 1.40 mg/L were found in 65.00% (845/1300) of children aged 8 to 12 years old, with the highest urinary fluoride concentrations as 18.53 mg/L. The rate of skeletal fluorosis by clinic and X-rays in adults older than 16 years old were 4.35% (1121/25 781) and 11.36% (5/44), respectively. The urinary fluoride values above 1.60 mg/L were found as 63.92% (606/948) in adults older than 16 years old, with the highest urinary fluoride concentrations as 21.35 mg/L.
The status of endemic fluorosis had not been effectively controlled and the situation for endemic fluorosis control was still critical in the floodplain area of the lower Yellow River in Shandong province, suggesting that the preventive approaches on endemic fluorosis control should be strengthened.
调查山东省黄河下游滩区地方性氟中毒的当前流行状况。
按照《2008年国家地方病防治技术方案》,选取16个县开展地方性氟中毒流行病学调查。每个县选取3个村,测定饮用水氟含量,检查8至12岁儿童的氟斑牙、16岁以上成年人的氟骨症。儿童和成年人都检测尿氟。饮用水和尿中的氟含量采用氟离子选择电极法测定,8至12岁儿童的氟斑牙采用迪恩氏法诊断,成年人氟骨症按照《地方性氟骨症诊断》国家标准(WS 192 - 2008)诊断。
调查在16个县的26个“改水”村进行,其中19个村水氟含量≤1.00mg/L,占73.08%(19/26),7个村水氟含量>1.00mg/L,占26.92%(7/26),水氟含量最高为3.73mg/L。在16个县的22个“未改水”村,5个村水氟含量≤1.00mg/L(占22.73%),17个村水氟含量>1.00mg/L(占77.27%),水氟含量最高为3.38mg/L。8至12岁儿童氟斑牙总患病率为52.18%(1042/1997),氟斑牙指数为1.17,牙齿缺损率为8.01%(160/1997)。8至12岁儿童中65.00%(845/1300)尿氟值高于1.40mg/L,尿氟最高浓度为18.53mg/L。16岁以上成年人临床诊断和X线诊断的氟骨症患病率分别为4.35%(1121/25781)和11.36%(5/44)。16岁以上成年人中63.92%(606/948)尿氟值高于1.60mg/L,尿氟最高浓度为2l.35mg/L。
山东省黄河下游滩区地方性氟中毒状况尚未得到有效控制,地方性氟中毒防治形势依然严峻,提示应加强地方性氟中毒防治措施。