KWR Watercycle Research Institute, Groningenhaven 7, 3433 PE Nieuwegein, The Netherlands.
Water Res. 2011 Feb;45(4):1847-55. doi: 10.1016/j.watres.2010.11.041. Epub 2010 Dec 4.
This study investigates the effects of very low concentrations of ClO(2) applied in drinking water practice on the inactivation of bacteriophage MS2. Concentrations of 0.5 mg/L, 0.1 mg/L and 0.02 mg/L ClO(2) inactivated at least 5 log units of MS2 after an exposure time of approximately 20, 50 and 300 min respectively. When the ClO(2) concentration was as low as 0.005 mg/L, inactivation of 1 log unit MS2 was observed after 300 min exposure. Increasing the contact time to 24 h did not increase the inactivation any further. Non-linear inactivation kinetics (tailing) were observed for all conditions tested. Repeated addition of MS2 to the reactor showed that tailing was not caused by a reduction of the biocidal effect of ClO(2) during disinfection. The Modified Chick-Watson, the Efficiency Factor Hom (EFH) model and the Modified Cerf model, a modification of the two-fraction Cerf model, were fitted to the non-linear inactivation curves. Both the EFH and the modified Cerf model did fit accurately to the inactivation data of all experiments. The good fit of the Modified Cerf model supports the hypothesis of the presence of two subpopulations. Our study showed that ClO(2) is an effective disinfectant against model organism MS2, also at the low concentrations applied in water treatment practice. The inactivation kinetics followed a biphasic pattern due to the presence of a more ClO(2)-resistant subpopulation of MS2 phages, either caused by population heterogeneity or aggregation/adhesion of MS2.
本研究调查了饮用水处理中极低浓度 ClO(2) 对噬菌体 MS2 灭活的影响。0.5mg/L、0.1mg/L 和 0.02mg/L 的 ClO(2) 浓度分别在大约 20、50 和 300 分钟的暴露时间后使 MS2 至少失活 5 个对数单位。当 ClO(2)浓度低至 0.005mg/L 时,在 300 分钟暴露后观察到 1 个对数单位 MS2 的失活。将接触时间延长至 24 小时不会进一步增加失活。所有测试条件下均观察到非线性失活动力学(滞后)。向反应器中重复添加 MS2 表明,滞后不是由于 ClO(2)在消毒过程中的杀菌效果降低所致。修正后的 Chick-Watson、效率因子 Hom(EFH)模型和修正后的 Cerf 模型(两部分 Cerf 模型的修正)被拟合到非线性失活曲线。EFH 和修正的 Cerf 模型都准确地拟合了所有实验的失活数据。修正后的 Cerf 模型的良好拟合支持存在两个亚群的假设。我们的研究表明,ClO(2)是一种有效的消毒剂,可有效灭活模型生物 MS2,即使在水处理实践中应用的低浓度下也是如此。由于存在对 ClO(2 更具抗性的 MS2 噬菌体亚群,失活动力学呈两相模式,这要么是由于种群异质性,要么是由于 MS2 的聚集/黏附。