McNeill Brigid C, Gillon Gail T, Dodd Barbara
College of Education, University of Canterbury, New Zealand.
Int J Speech Lang Pathol. 2009;11(6):482-95. doi: 10.3109/17549500902842583.
This study is an examination of the longitudinal effects of an integrated phonological awareness approach for identical twin boys with childhood apraxia of speech (CAS). Genetic and environmental factors in the boys' responses to the intervention were also examined. Theo and Jamie (aged 4;5) each participated in 18 hours of intervention prior to school entry and were re-assessed at age 4;9, 5;3, and 5;9 respectively. Their speech, expressive morpho-syntactic, phonological awareness, reading, and spelling development were evaluated over their first year of schooling. Theo and Jamie experienced continued growth in speech and phonological awareness skills following participation in the intervention. They exhibited age-appropriate reading and spelling development during their first year of formal literacy instruction. They had persistent deficits in expressive morpho-syntactic skills despite speech production gains over the study. The results pointed to the benefit of integrating speech and phonological awareness goals within a preventative framework to ensure successful early literacy development for children with CAS. Findings suggested that language difficulties in children with CAS should be targeted during intervention as they do not resolve as the children's speech production difficulties minimize.
本研究考察了一种综合语音意识方法对患有儿童言语失用症(CAS)的同卵双胞胎男孩的纵向影响。同时也研究了男孩们对干预措施反应中的遗传和环境因素。西奥和杰米(4岁5个月)在入学前各自接受了18小时的干预,并分别在4岁9个月、5岁3个月和5岁9个月时接受重新评估。在他们入学的第一年里,对他们的言语、表达形态句法、语音意识、阅读和拼写发展进行了评估。西奥和杰米在参与干预后,言语和语音意识技能持续增长。在接受正式读写教学的第一年里,他们展现出了符合年龄的阅读和拼写发展。尽管在研究过程中言语产生能力有所提高,但他们在表达形态句法技能方面仍存在持续的缺陷。结果表明,在预防框架内整合言语和语音意识目标,有利于确保患有CAS的儿童早期读写能力的成功发展。研究结果表明,CAS儿童的语言困难在干预期间应作为目标,因为随着儿童言语产生困难的减少,这些语言困难并不会得到解决。