Department of Nursing, Meiho University, Pingtung and School of Nursing, Kaohsiung Medical University, Kaohsiung, Taiwan.
J Clin Nurs. 2012 Mar;21(5-6):636-43. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2702.2010.03531.x. Epub 2011 Feb 20.
The aim of this study was to examine whether the application of cryotherapy with ice in a plastic bag is effective in reducing the severity of wound pain after arthroscopy.
In most studies, analgesic medication were administered prior to surgery; postoperative pain may be reduced by analgesics, but they are known to confound the effects of cryotherapy. Cryotherapy by Cryocuff system has commonly been used to manage post arthroscopy patients' pain. Few studies have tested the effects of cryotherapy by simply applying ice in a plastic bag to relieve postarthroscopy pain.
This was a prospective, double-blinded, quasi-experimental study with two groups, interrupted time-series design and multiple treatment replications.
Fifty-nine patients who received arthroscopy between July-August 2007 were assigned to receive cryotherapy (the experimental group, 33 people) or no cryotherapy (the control group, 26 people). For the experimental group, three 10-minute sessions of ice packing were conducted over a three-hour period, with 50-minute intervals between each session. The first session of ice packing was applied immediately after recovery from anaesthesia.
Cryotherapy with ice in a plastic bag was shown to be effective in lessening the degree of pain in postarthroscopy patients. The pain score of the experimental group decreased from 5·12-1·82 after cryotherapy, representing a significant decrease, while the pain score in the control group decreased from 4·04-2·88 (p = 0·047, 0·012 and 0·005).
Cryotherapy with ice in a plastic bag can be applied in standard protocols for patients who have just undergone arthroscopic surgery.
Cryotherapy with ice in a plastic bag is a simple, readily attainable and cost-effective technique for relieving postarthroscopy pain. We recommend that it be included in standard treatment protocols. Techniques for cryotherapy should be incorporated into in-service education.
本研究旨在探讨在关节镜检查后,将冰袋中的冰敷应用于伤口是否能有效减轻伤口疼痛的严重程度。
在大多数研究中,手术前会使用镇痛药物;术后疼痛可以通过镇痛药来减轻,但已知这会影响冰敷的效果。Cryocuff 系统的冰敷已广泛用于治疗关节镜检查后的患者疼痛。很少有研究测试简单地将冰袋应用于伤口以缓解关节镜检查后疼痛的效果。
这是一项前瞻性、双盲、准实验研究,采用两组、中断时间序列设计和多次治疗重复。
2007 年 7 月至 8 月期间接受关节镜检查的 59 名患者被分配接受冰敷(实验组,33 人)或不接受冰敷(对照组,26 人)。实验组在三小时内进行三次 10 分钟的冰敷,每次冰敷之间间隔 50 分钟。第一次冰敷在麻醉恢复后立即进行。
将冰袋中的冰敷应用于关节镜检查后的患者,可有效减轻疼痛程度。实验组的疼痛评分从冰敷前的 5.12 分降至冰敷后的 1.82 分,降幅显著,而对照组的疼痛评分从 4.04 分降至 2.88 分(p = 0.047、0.012 和 0.005)。
将冰袋中的冰敷应用于刚刚接受关节镜手术的患者的标准方案中是有效的。
将冰袋中的冰敷应用于关节镜检查后的患者,是一种简单、易得且具有成本效益的缓解术后疼痛的方法。我们建议将其纳入标准治疗方案中。冰敷技术应纳入在职教育中。