Ghosh Sambuddha, Mukhopadhyay Subhalakshmi, Dutta Subir Kumar, Chattopadhyay Debnath, Biswas Kaushick
Regional Institute of Ophthalmology, Kolkata 700073.
J Indian Med Assoc. 2010 Aug;108(8):509, 512-3.
This study was done to ascertain the accuracy of diagnosis and possible risk of misdiagnosis in suspected retinoblastoma cases by different pre-operative diagnostic procedures like fundoscopy, ultrasonography, computerised tomography, and aqueous cytology study. Twenty-four eyes excised with diagnosis of suspected retinoblastoma were included in the study. Final diagnosis was reached by histopathological examination of excised eyes and compared with pre-operative diagnosis by different diagnostic procedures and accuracy of each procedure was calculated. Twenty-two cases were finally diagnosed as retinoblastoma and 2 cases (8.33%) as other than retinoblastoma. Computerised tomography and aqueous humour cytology were two most specific (100%) tests. Computerised tomography was the most sensitive (95.4%) test. Aqueous cytology was poorly sensitive (9.09%). Both ultrasonography and fundoscopy demonstrated sensitivity over 90% but with low specificity (50%). When test results of fundoscopy and ultrasonography were combined, specificity of this combination was 100% and sensitivity was 95.4%, which match exactly the values of computerised tomography. Combination of fundoscopy and ultrasonography has accuracy as high as that of computerised tomography. In patients with clear media this combination can be used as an effective alternative to computerised tomography to reach a diagnosis with comparable accuracy.
本研究旨在通过眼底镜检查、超声检查、计算机断层扫描和房水细胞学研究等不同的术前诊断程序,确定疑似视网膜母细胞瘤病例的诊断准确性和可能的误诊风险。本研究纳入了24只经诊断为疑似视网膜母细胞瘤而切除的眼睛。通过对切除眼睛的组织病理学检查得出最终诊断,并与不同诊断程序的术前诊断进行比较,计算每种程序的准确性。最终诊断为视网膜母细胞瘤的有22例,非视网膜母细胞瘤的有2例(8.33%)。计算机断层扫描和房水细胞学是两种最具特异性(100%)的检查。计算机断层扫描是最敏感(95.4%)的检查。房水细胞学的敏感性较差(9.09%)。超声检查和眼底镜检查的敏感性均超过90%,但特异性较低(50%)。当眼底镜检查和超声检查的结果相结合时,这种联合检查的特异性为100%,敏感性为95.4%,与计算机断层扫描的值完全匹配。眼底镜检查和超声检查的联合具有与计算机断层扫描一样高的准确性。在屈光间质清晰的患者中,这种联合检查可作为计算机断层扫描的有效替代方法,以达到具有可比准确性的诊断。