Siddiqui Faisal Ghani, Shaikh Jan Mohammad, Memon Mohammad Munir
Department of Surgery, Liaquat University of Medical & Health Sciences, Jamshoro, Pakistan.
J Ayub Med Coll Abbottabad. 2010 Jan-Mar;22(1):133-5.
To obtain informed consent is considered an integral part of modern clinical practice. It works as a safeguard of patient's rights and minimizes the chances of legal action against the physician in case of any complication arising from the proposed therapy. Objective was to evaluate the practice of informed consent in patients undergoing surgery in a University hospital.
A survey was conducted at different surgical departments of a university hospital during December 2007 to March 2008. Participants were selected from patients over the age of 18 years who had undergone elective or emergency surgery. All interviews were based on structured questionnaire. The patients were asked if an informed consent was taken or not before the surgery. They were also inquired if they were given information about the diagnosis, the surgical procedure planned and risks associated with it. The patients were also asked if they were informed about the types of anaesthesia proposed.
A total of 106 patients were randomly selected for this study. In 8.5% cases, no consent was taken. Only 38% of the surveyed patients acknowledged that they actually understood the information imparted to them. 66% patients were informed about the type of anaesthesia proposed but none was given any hint about complications of anaesthesia. 11% patients actually signed the consent forms themselves.
The quality of existing informed consent process in a university hospital is less than ideal. There is a great need to educate the doctors and healthcare regarding the importance of patient's autonomy and their right to the information about their medical condition and the proposed surgical procedures to ensure their participation in the decision making regarding their treatment.
获得知情同意被视为现代临床实践的一个组成部分。它是对患者权利的一种保护,并在拟议治疗引发任何并发症的情况下,将针对医生的法律诉讼可能性降至最低。目的是评估一所大学医院中接受手术患者的知情同意实践情况。
于2007年12月至2008年3月期间在一所大学医院的不同外科科室进行了一项调查。参与者选自18岁以上接受择期或急诊手术的患者。所有访谈均基于结构化问卷。询问患者手术前是否获得了知情同意。还询问他们是否被告知诊断情况、计划的手术程序及其相关风险。也询问患者是否被告知拟用的麻醉类型。
本研究共随机选取了106名患者。在8.5%的病例中,未取得同意。只有38%的受访患者承认他们真正理解了传达给他们的信息。66%的患者被告知拟用的麻醉类型,但无人被告知任何有关麻醉并发症的提示。11%的患者实际亲自签署了同意书。
一所大学医院中现有知情同意流程的质量不尽人意。非常有必要对医生和医护人员进行关于患者自主权的重要性以及他们有权了解自身病情和拟议手术程序的教育,以确保他们参与有关其治疗的决策。