Rosenthal D, Evans R D, McKinsey J, Seagraves M A, Lamis P A, Clark M D, Daniel W W
Georgia Baptist Medical Center, Department of Vascular Surgery, Atlanta.
J Cardiovasc Surg (Torino). 1990 Jul-Aug;31(4):462-8.
There is no consensus about the most appropriate management of the patient with intermittent claudication due to a superficial femoral artery occlusion. To evaluate the natural history of prosthetic above-knee femoropopliteal (AKFP) bypass, 200 operations for intermittent claudication were reviewed. One hundred AKFP bypasses were done with PTFE and 100 with dacron. In the 30 day postoperative period, four PTFE and three dacron grafts occluded without consequence and only one patient died. Analysis of results by the life-table method demonstrated statistically similar primary graft patency rates at five years (PTFE 65% SE +/- 6.5, dacron 57% +/- 6.2) and ten years (PTFE 31% +/- 18/9, dacron 32% +/- 13.2) (p greater than 0.10). Redo procedures (e.g., thrombectomy, angioplasty) were necessary on 21 grafts (12 PTFE, 9 dacron) and "secondary" patency rates at five years were 76% PTFE and 62% dacron; no grafts which required a redo procedure were patent at ten year follow-up. Major amputations during ten year follow-up were necessary in 16 (8%) patients; all amputations were in diabetic patients. Survival rates were 79% at five and 42% at ten years. An anticipated, the leading cause of death was cardiac related (25 patients); 28 (14%) patients underwent aortocoronary bypass during follow-up. A prosthetic AKFP bypass graft is a safe and durable operation which provides relief from the symptoms of intermittent claudication while allowing for the preservation of the saphenous vein for use later in the coronary or infrapopliteal circulations, should the need arise. These results indicate that the risk of amputation after AKFP is no greater than the natural history of untreated claudication; however, AKFP offers a significant improvement in life-style.
对于因股浅动脉闭塞导致间歇性跛行的患者,目前尚无关于最合适治疗方法的共识。为了评估人工膝上股腘(AKFP)旁路移植术的自然病程,回顾了200例因间歇性跛行而进行的手术。其中100例AKFP旁路移植术使用聚四氟乙烯(PTFE),100例使用涤纶。术后30天内,4例PTFE和3例涤纶移植物闭塞但无不良后果,仅1例患者死亡。采用寿命表法分析结果显示,5年时(PTFE 65%,标准误±6.5,涤纶57%±6.2)和10年时(PTFE 31%±18/9,涤纶32%±13.2)的原发性移植物通畅率在统计学上相似(p大于0.10)。21例移植物(12例PTFE,9例涤纶)需要再次手术(如血栓切除术、血管成形术),5年时的“继发性”通畅率PTFE为76%,涤纶为62%;在10年随访时,所有需要再次手术的移植物均未通畅。10年随访期间,16例(8%)患者需要进行大截肢手术;所有截肢患者均为糖尿病患者。5年生存率为79%,10年生存率为42%。不出所料,主要死亡原因与心脏相关(25例患者);28例(14%)患者在随访期间接受了主动脉冠状动脉旁路移植术。人工AKFP旁路移植术是一种安全且持久的手术,可缓解间歇性跛行症状,同时在必要时保留大隐静脉以备日后用于冠状动脉或腘下循环。这些结果表明,AKFP术后截肢风险不高于未经治疗的间歇性跛行的自然病程;然而,AKFP可显著改善生活方式。